Aguirre Sophia, Jogerst Kristen M, Ginsberg Zachary, Voleti Sandeep, Bhullar Puneet, Spegman Joshua, Viggiano Taylor, Monas Jessica, Rappaport Douglas
Mayo Clinic, Alix School of Medicine, Phoenix, AZ, USA.
Department of General Surgery, Mayo Clinic Arizona, Phoenix, AZ, USA.
Bull Emerg Trauma. 2021 Jul;9(3):125-132. doi: 10.30476/BEAT.2021.89058.1216.
To investigate in how the current COVID-19 pandemic affects patient's perceptions of emergency physician empathy and communication.
Patients cared for by Emergency Department physicians with the lowest satisfaction scores were surveyed within one week of discharge via phone. Using questions from the Consultation and Relational Empathy (CARE) survey, patients rated their satisfaction with their Emergency provider's empathy and communication on a scale of 1 to 5 and provided feedback on how the patient-provider interaction could be improved. Demographic data and patient responses to CARE survey questions were compared between pre-COVID-19 and during COVID-19 time. Patient's open-ended responses were analyzed for themes related to the impact of COVID-19 on the patient-provider relationship.
Patient median quantitative scores were 5 (4-5) across all five questions of pre-COVID-19 and 5 (4-5) during COVID-19 for all questions except two (showing care and compassion), median 5(5-5). Female patients rated provider empathy and communication lower than mens. There was no differences across age strata. A shift in provider focuses to COVID-19 only care (N=3), and an understanding of the stress on healthcare processes (N=13) from open-ended responses themes emerged of patients who want to minimize interactions within the emergency department (N=3).
The external factor of the current pandemic did not negatively impact patient's satisfaction scores. Many patients express leniency and gratitude for emergency providers during this challenging time. Their responses seem to mirror current societal views of frontline healthcare workers.
调查当前新冠疫情如何影响患者对急诊医生同理心和沟通的认知。
通过电话对出院一周内由满意度得分最低的急诊科医生诊治的患者进行调查。使用咨询与关系同理心(CARE)调查问卷中的问题,患者对急诊医护人员的同理心和沟通满意度进行1至5分的评分,并就如何改善医患互动提供反馈。比较了新冠疫情前和疫情期间的人口统计学数据以及患者对CARE调查问卷问题的回答。对患者的开放式回答进行分析,以找出与新冠疫情对医患关系影响相关的主题。
在新冠疫情前的所有五个问题中,患者的定量得分中位数为5(4 - 5),在新冠疫情期间,除两个问题(表现出关心和同情)中位数为5(5 - 5)外,其他所有问题的得分中位数均为5(4 - 5)。女性患者对医护人员同理心和沟通的评分低于男性。各年龄层之间没有差异。从开放式回答主题中发现,医护人员的关注点转向仅治疗新冠患者(N = 3),以及理解医疗流程中的压力(N = 13),有患者希望尽量减少在急诊科的互动(N = 3)。
当前疫情的外部因素并未对患者满意度得分产生负面影响。在这个充满挑战的时期,许多患者对急诊医护人员表示宽容和感激。他们的回答似乎反映了当前社会对一线医护人员的看法。