Department of Family and Social Medicine, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, NY, USA.
Department of Medicine, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, NY, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 2022 Jan;37(1):130-136. doi: 10.1007/s11606-021-06921-3. Epub 2021 Jul 29.
Seriously ill patients in low-income and minority populations have lower rates of advance care planning. Initiatives that promote serious illness (SI) conversations in community health centers (CHCs) can reach broad, diverse patient populations. This qualitative study explored the experiences of primary care physicians in conducting SI conversations at CHCs in order to understand challenges and needs in this setting.
An initiative to increase SI conversations was implemented at two CHCs in the Bronx, NY. Eleven participating family physicians who together conducted 37 SI conversations underwent semi-structured in-depth interviews. The 11 interviews were analyzed using inductive thematic analysis.
Eight themes emerged: (1) Structured approaches to SI conversations are useful even in longstanding patient-doctor relationships; (2) Discussion of prognosis is meaningful but difficult; (3) Emotional work is humanizing but draining; (4) Poverty and underinsurance are high priorities; (5) Social context affects patient readiness; (6) Communication barriers take multiple forms; (7) Patient characteristics make it "easier" or "harder" to initiate the SI conversation; (8) Time constraints limit the ability to meet multiple patient needs.
Physicians at CHCs identified challenges in SI conversations at personal, interpersonal, organizational, and societal levels. These challenges should be addressed by initiatives that aim to increase SI conversations in primary care, and especially at CHCs.
在低收入和少数族裔人群中,重病患者进行预先护理计划的比率较低。在社区卫生中心(CHC)推动严重疾病(SI)对话的举措可以覆盖广泛的、多样化的患者群体。本定性研究探讨了初级保健医生在 CHC 进行 SI 对话的经验,以了解在这种环境下的挑战和需求。
在纽约布朗克斯的两家 CHC 实施了一项增加 SI 对话的计划。11 名参与的家庭医生共同进行了 37 次 SI 对话,他们接受了半结构化的深入访谈。对 11 次访谈进行了归纳主题分析。
出现了八个主题:(1)即使在长期的医患关系中,SI 对话的结构化方法也是有用的;(2)预后讨论具有意义但很困难;(3)情感工作具有人性化但很耗费精力;(4)贫困和保险不足是重中之重;(5)社会背景影响患者的准备情况;(6)沟通障碍有多种形式;(7)患者特征使启动 SI 对话“更容易”或“更难”;(8)时间限制限制了满足多个患者需求的能力。
CHC 的医生确定了在个人、人际、组织和社会层面上进行 SI 对话的挑战。旨在增加初级保健,特别是在 CHC 中进行 SI 对话的举措应解决这些挑战。