Vagedes Jan, Kuderer Silja, Helmert Eduard, Kohl Matthias, Beissner Florian, Szöke Henrik, Joos Stefanie, Wolf Ursula
ARCIM Institute (Academic Research in Complementary and Integrative Medicine), Im Haberschlai 7, 70794 Filderstadt, Germany.
Department of Neonatology, University Hospital Tuebingen, Calwerstraße 7, 72076 Tuebingen, Germany.
Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2021 Jul 12;2021:9981183. doi: 10.1155/2021/9981183. eCollection 2021.
To examine the effects of warm footbaths with thermogenic medicinal powders on vitality and heart rate variability in healthy adults. . Seventeen healthy young adults (22.1 ± 2.4 years, 11 females) received three footbaths (WA: warm water only; GI: warm water and ginger; MU: warm water and mustard) in randomized order with a crossover design. We assessed vitality with the Basler Befindlichkeit questionnaire (BBS) and heart rate variability (HRV) before (0), immediately after (1), and 10 minutes following footbaths (2). The primary outcome measure was self-reported vitality, measured via the BBS, at 1.
The primary outcome measure, self-reported vitality, was higher after GI and tended to be higher after MU compared to WA with medium effect sizes (GI vs. WA, mean difference -2.47 (95% CI -5.28 to 0.34), =0.048, = 0.74), MU vs. WA, -2.35 (-5.32 to 0.61), =0.30, = 0.50). At 2, the standard deviation of beat-to-beat intervals (SDNN) of HRV increased, and the stress index tended to decrease after all three footbath conditions with small to medium effect sizes (0.42-0.66).
There is preliminary evidence that footbaths with thermogenic agents GI and MU may increase self-reported vitality during a short-time period with a more pronounced effect with GI. After a short follow-up, all three conditions tended to shift the autonomic balance towards relaxation. Future research should investigate these effects in clinical samples with a larger, more diverse sample size.
研究使用含温热生药粉的足浴对健康成年人活力及心率变异性的影响。17名健康青年成年人(年龄22.1±2.4岁,女性11名)采用交叉设计,随机接受三种足浴(WA:仅用温水;GI:温水加生姜;MU:温水加芥末)。我们在足浴前(0分钟)、足浴后即刻(1分钟)和足浴后10分钟(2分钟),使用巴塞尔状态问卷(BBS)评估活力,并测量心率变异性(HRV)。主要结局指标为通过BBS在1分钟时自我报告的活力。结果:主要结局指标,即自我报告的活力,在GI足浴后更高,与WA相比,MU足浴后也有升高趋势,效应量中等(GI与WA相比,平均差值-2.47(95%CI-5.28至0.34),P=0.048,Cohen's d=0.74),MU与WA相比,-2.35(-5.32至0.61),P=0.30,Cohen's d=0.50)。在2分钟时,所有三种足浴条件下HRV的逐搏间期标准差(SDNN)均增加,应激指数有下降趋势,效应量小到中等(0.42-0.66)。结论:有初步证据表明,含温热剂GI和MU的足浴可能在短时间内提高自我报告的活力,GI的效果更显著。经过短期随访,所有三种条件都倾向于使自主神经平衡向放松方向转变。未来的研究应在更大、更多样化的临床样本中研究这些效应。