Ferrari Federico, Imperato Chiara, Mancini Tiziana
Department of Humanities, Social Sciences, and Cultural Industry, University of Parma, Parma, Italy.
Front Psychol. 2021 Jul 29;12:686974. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.686974. eCollection 2021.
Within the framework of the System Justification Theory, this study tested on the archival data from 16 European countries the general hypothesis that homonegativity (HN), as an expression of gender binarism and heteronormativity, works as a legitimizing myth of gender hierarchy. Specifically, we hypothesized that (1) system justification (SJ) would positively relate to HN and (2) this relation would depend on the country level of gender hierarchy, (3) on the gender of respondents, and (4) on the interaction between gender hierarchy and gender. We selected the Gender Equality Index (GEI) as an indicator of the gender hierarchy of the country system and the items from the European Social Survey-Round 9 (ESS-9) as the indicators of the gender of respondents and the levels of SJ and HN. The Hierarchical Linear Modeling (HLM) partially confirmed the hypotheses, suggesting HN to work as a blatant prejudice and being more viable as a legitimizing myth in females from countries with higher gender hierarchy and in males from more gender-equal countries. In both cases, HN serves as a myth to justify the ontological premise of participants that the world is fair and to counteract the cognitive dissonance generated by the perception of a gender-unequal system (in the case of a woman) or by the perception of a gender-equal system that can threaten gender privileges (in the case of a man).
在系统正当性理论的框架内,本研究基于16个欧洲国家的档案数据,对一个一般性假设进行了检验,即作为性别二元论和异性恋规范表达的同性恋否定性(HN),是性别等级制度的一种正当化神话。具体而言,我们假设:(1)系统正当性(SJ)与HN呈正相关;(2)这种关系将取决于国家层面的性别等级制度;(3)取决于受访者的性别;(4)取决于性别等级制度与性别的相互作用。我们选择性别平等指数(GEI)作为国家系统性别等级制度的指标,并选取欧洲社会调查第9轮(ESS - 9)中的项目作为受访者性别、SJ和HN水平的指标。分层线性模型(HLM)部分证实了这些假设,表明HN作为一种公然的偏见,在性别等级制度较高国家的女性以及性别更平等国家的男性中,作为一种正当化神话更为可行。在这两种情况下,HN都作为一种神话,来证明参与者关于世界是公平的本体论前提,并抵消因感知到性别不平等系统(对女性而言)或因感知到可能威胁性别特权的性别平等系统(对男性而言)而产生的认知失调。