Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation, Seattle, Washington.
Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland.
JAMA. 2021 Aug 17;326(7):649-659. doi: 10.1001/jama.2021.9937.
Measuring health care spending by race and ethnicity is important for understanding patterns in utilization and treatment.
To estimate, identify, and account for differences in health care spending by race and ethnicity from 2002 through 2016 in the US.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This exploratory study included data from 7.3 million health system visits, admissions, or prescriptions captured in the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (2002-2016) and the Medicare Current Beneficiary Survey (2002-2012), which were combined with the insured population and notified case estimates from the National Health Interview Survey (2002; 2016) and health care spending estimates from the Disease Expenditure project (1996-2016).
Six mutually exclusive self-reported race and ethnicity groups.
Total and age-standardized health care spending per person by race and ethnicity for each year from 2002 through 2016 by type of care. Health care spending per notified case by race and ethnicity for key diseases in 2016. Differences in health care spending across race and ethnicity groups were decomposed into differences in utilization rate vs differences in price and intensity of care.
In 2016, an estimated $2.4 trillion (95% uncertainty interval [UI], $2.4 trillion-$2.4 trillion) was spent on health care across the 6 types of care included in this study. The estimated age-standardized total health care spending per person in 2016 was $7649 (95% UI, $6129-$8814) for American Indian and Alaska Native (non-Hispanic) individuals; $4692 (95% UI, $4068-$5202) for Asian, Native Hawaiian, and Pacific Islander (non-Hispanic) individuals; $7361 (95% UI, $6917-$7797) for Black (non-Hispanic) individuals; $6025 (95% UI, $5703-$6373) for Hispanic individuals; $9276 (95% UI, $8066-$10 601) for individuals categorized as multiple races (non-Hispanic); and $8141 (95% UI, $8038-$8258) for White (non-Hispanic) individuals, who accounted for an estimated 72% (95% UI, 71%-73%) of health care spending. After adjusting for population size and age, White individuals received an estimated 15% (95% UI, 13%-17%; P < .001) more spending on ambulatory care than the all-population mean. Black (non-Hispanic) individuals received an estimated 26% (95% UI, 19%-32%; P < .001) less spending than the all-population mean on ambulatory care but received 19% (95% UI, 3%-32%; P = .02) more on inpatient and 12% (95% UI, 4%-24%; P = .04) more on emergency department care. Hispanic individuals received an estimated 33% (95% UI, 26%-37%; P < .001) less spending per person on ambulatory care than the all-population mean. Asian, Native Hawaiian, and Pacific Islander (non-Hispanic) individuals received less spending than the all-population mean on all types of care except dental (all P < .001), while American Indian and Alaska Native (non-Hispanic) individuals had more spending on emergency department care than the all-population mean (estimated 90% more; 95% UI, 11%-165%; P = .04), and multiple-race (non-Hispanic) individuals had more spending on emergency department care than the all-population mean (estimated 40% more; 95% UI, 19%-63%; P = .006). All 18 of the statistically significant race and ethnicity spending differences by type of care corresponded with differences in utilization. These differences persisted when controlling for underlying disease burden.
In the US from 2002 through 2016, health care spending varied by race and ethnicity across different types of care even after adjusting for age and health conditions. Further research is needed to determine current health care spending by race and ethnicity, including spending related to the COVID-19 pandemic.
重要性:衡量医疗保健支出的种族和民族差异对于了解利用和治疗模式非常重要。
目的:从 2002 年到 2016 年,估计、识别和解释美国种族和民族之间的医疗保健支出差异。
设计、设置和参与者:这项探索性研究包括了来自医疗支出面板调查(2002-2016 年)和医疗保险当前受益人大调查(2002-2012 年)的数据,这两个调查与国家健康访谈调查(2002 年;2016 年)的参保人群和通知病例估计数以及疾病支出项目(1996-2016 年)的医疗保健支出估计数相结合。
暴露因素:六个相互排斥的自我报告种族和民族群体。
主要结果和措施:2002 年至 2016 年期间,每年各类护理的种族和民族之间的人均医疗保健支出总额和年龄标准化支出,以及 2016 年主要疾病的通知病例的种族和民族之间的医疗保健支出差异。利用率和价格强度的差异分解了种族和民族群体之间的医疗保健支出差异。
结果:在 2016 年,估计有 2.4 万亿美元(95%不确定区间[UI],2.4 万亿美元-2.4 万亿美元)用于包括在这项研究中的六种护理类型的医疗保健。2016 年,美国印第安人和阿拉斯加原住民(非西班牙裔)个体的年龄标准化人均总医疗保健支出估计为 7649 美元(95% UI,6129 美元-8814 美元);亚洲人、夏威夷原住民和太平洋岛民(非西班牙裔)个体为 4692 美元(95% UI,4068 美元-5202 美元);黑人(非西班牙裔)个体为 7361 美元(95% UI,6917 美元-7797 美元);西班牙裔个体为 6025 美元(95% UI,5703 美元-6373 美元);多种族(非西班牙裔)个体为 9276 美元(95% UI,8066 美元-10601 美元);白人(非西班牙裔)个体为 8141 美元(95% UI,8038 美元-8258 美元),占医疗保健支出的估计 72%(95% UI,71%-73%)。在调整人口规模和年龄后,白人个体估计比总人口平均值多花费 15%(95% UI,13%-17%;P<0.001)用于门诊护理。黑人(非西班牙裔)个体估计比总人口平均值少花费 26%(95% UI,19%-32%;P<0.001)用于门诊护理,但住院和急诊部门护理分别多花费 19%(95% UI,3%-32%;P=0.02)和 12%(95% UI,4%-24%;P=0.04)。西班牙裔个体估计比总人口平均值少花费 33%(95% UI,26%-37%;P<0.001)用于门诊护理。亚洲人、夏威夷原住民和太平洋岛民(非西班牙裔)个体除了牙科(所有 P<0.001)之外,所有类型的护理都比总人口平均值少,而美洲印第安人和阿拉斯加原住民(非西班牙裔)个体在急诊部门护理上的花费比总人口平均值多估计 90%(95% UI,11%-165%;P=0.04),多种族(非西班牙裔)个体在急诊部门护理上的花费比总人口平均值多估计 40%(95% UI,19%-63%;P=0.006)。18 种按护理类型划分的具有统计学意义的种族和民族支出差异都与利用的差异相对应。这些差异在控制疾病负担后仍然存在。
结论和相关性:在美国,2002 年至 2016 年期间,即使在调整了年龄和健康状况后,不同类型的护理中,种族和民族之间的医疗保健支出也存在差异。需要进一步研究当前的种族和民族医疗保健支出,包括与 COVID-19 大流行相关的支出。