Beukelman David R, Thiessen Amber, Fager Susan Koch
Department of Special Education and Communication Disorders, University of Nebraska-Lincoln, Lincoln, Nebraska.
Madonna Rehabilitation Hospital, Lincoln, Nebraska.
Top Lang Disord. 2021;41(3):e1-e11.
Visual scene displays (VSDs) are becoming an increasingly popular method of message representation within augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) supports; however, design factors can influence the effectiveness of these images as communication supports. One issue that has come to light in recent years is the fact that selecting personalized VSDs, which depict the person with complex communication needs or an individual with whom they are familiar, are preferred over generic VSDs, which depict unfamiliar individuals. Although personalization is likely an important factor in the usability of VSDs, these images may be difficult for clinicians to obtain. As such, compromises must be identified. The purpose of this study was to explore the effects of controlling personal relevance factors (i.e., age and gender of the people depicted in generic VSDs) on the image preference patterns of adults with and without aphasia. Results from three very preliminary study summaries indicate that gender and age are both mitigating factors in image preference, as males tended to indicate preference for VSDs containing males over those containing females. In addition, females tended to indicate preference for females of a similar age depicted in VSDs.
视觉场景显示(VSDs)在辅助和替代沟通(AAC)支持中已成为一种越来越流行的信息呈现方式;然而,设计因素会影响这些图像作为沟通支持的有效性。近年来出现的一个问题是,与描绘不熟悉个体的通用VSD相比,选择描绘有复杂沟通需求的人或其熟悉的人的个性化VSD更受青睐。尽管个性化可能是VSD可用性的一个重要因素,但临床医生可能难以获得这些图像。因此,必须找到折衷办法。本研究的目的是探讨控制个人相关因素(即通用VSD中描绘的人物的年龄和性别)对有失语症和无失语症成年人图像偏好模式的影响。三项非常初步的研究总结结果表明,性别和年龄都是影响图像偏好的缓和因素,因为男性倾向于表示更喜欢包含男性的VSD,而不是包含女性的VSD。此外,女性倾向于表示更喜欢VSD中描绘的年龄相仿的女性。