Department of Politics and Society, CARMA, Aalborg University, 9220 Aalborg, Denmark.
Department of Sociology and Social Work, CASTOR, Aalborg University, 9220 Aalborg, Denmark.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021 Aug 30;18(17):9156. doi: 10.3390/ijerph18179156.
Active ageing has been discussed in international political organisations and among researchers as a major means for combatting the challenges of demographic ageing. This study aims to make a critical-theoretical and empirical assessment of the active ageing concept, challenging the active ageing discourse from two different angles. First, an assessment of the theoretical framework of active ageing shows that the conceptual framework is undertheorised, lacks conceptual and analytical clarity, and fails to propose clear contributing factors and barriers. The second part presents an empirical analysis of the concept of active ageing guided by the following research question: is active ageing realistic-and for whom? Using Danish data subjected to multiple correspondence analysis, it is found that active ageing at the individual level is preconditioned by health, education, having good finances, etc. Furthermore, a Matthew effect of accumulated advantage is found; that is, older adults who are blessed in one sphere of life are also blessed in others, and such inequalities in old age are the outcomes of social life biographies (i.e., cumulative advantages/disadvantages over the life course). Thus, empirical findings indicate that active ageing may be an elusive goal for a large segment of older adults.
积极老龄化在国际政治组织和研究人员中被讨论为应对人口老龄化挑战的主要手段。本研究旨在对积极老龄化概念进行批判性理论和实证评估,从两个不同角度对积极老龄化话语提出挑战。首先,对积极老龄化理论框架的评估表明,该概念框架缺乏理论化、概念和分析上的清晰度,并且未能提出明确的促成因素和障碍。第二部分以以下研究问题为指导,对积极老龄化概念进行实证分析:积极老龄化是否现实——对于谁而言?通过对丹麦数据进行多元对应分析,发现个体层面的积极老龄化受到健康、教育、良好的财务状况等因素的制约。此外,还发现了累积优势的马太效应,即一个领域幸福的老年人在其他领域也会幸福,老年时期的这种不平等是社会生活传记的结果(即,一生中累积的优势/劣势)。因此,实证研究结果表明,积极老龄化对于很大一部分老年人来说可能是一个难以实现的目标。