Department of Periodontology, Faculty of Odontology, University of Malmö, Malmö, Sweden.
Division of Oral Surgery, University Clinic of Dentistry, Medical University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria.
Clin Oral Investig. 2022 Feb;26(2):1903-1913. doi: 10.1007/s00784-021-04167-1. Epub 2021 Sep 18.
To assess whether bacterial colonisation in a power-driven water flosser can be prevented.
Twenty-four patients undergoing supportive periodontal treatment used 2 power-driven water flossers [Sonicare AirFloss (SAF), AirFloss Ultra (SAFU)] for 12 weeks each as follows: (a) with bottled water (BW); (b) with BW and cleaning the device extra-orally twice per week with chlorhexidine gluconate or (c) essential-oil-based (EO) mouth-rinse; (d) with EO only. Water-jet samples were taken after 6 and 12 weeks with the used nozzle and after exchanging to a brand-new nozzle. After 12 weeks, all devices underwent an intensive cleaning procedure. Samples were analysed by PCR-based method for cariogenic and periodontal pathogens and culture for staphylococci, aerobe gram-negative bacteria, and Candida sp.
Contamination of SAF/SAFU with Streptococcus mutans was found in > 95% of the samples; periodontal pathogens and aerobe gram-negative bacteria were detected in 19-56% of the samples, while Staphylococcus aureus and Candida sp. were identified only in few samples. Contamination rate was basically unaffected by time-point, device, or way of use. Further, exchanging the nozzle did not prevent transmission of a contaminated water-jet, but the intensive cleaning reduced most of the pathogens significantly, except of S. mutans.
Neither a specific way of use nor exchanging the nozzle prevented bacterial colonisation and transmission of biofilm components via the water-jet of SAF/SAFU.
Bacterial colonisation in a power-driven water flosser seems impossible to prevent; to restrict the risk of cross-contamination within a household, one device per person should be recommended.
评估电动冲牙器是否可以防止细菌定植。
24 名接受牙周支持治疗的患者分别使用 2 种电动冲牙器[ Sonicare AirFloss(SAF)、AirFloss Ultra(SAFU)],持续 12 周,具体如下:(a)使用瓶装水(BW);(b)每周在 BW 之外,使用洗必泰葡萄糖酸或(c)含油基漱口水(EO)对设备进行两次口腔外清洁,或(d)仅使用 EO。在第 6 周和第 12 周以及更换全新喷嘴后,使用用过的喷嘴采集水射流样本。12 周后,所有设备均进行了深度清洁程序。通过基于 PCR 的方法和培养法分析样本,检测致龋和牙周病原体以及葡萄球菌、需氧革兰氏阴性菌和念珠菌。
在 SAF/SAFU 中发现超过 95%的样本中存在变形链球菌污染;在 19%-56%的样本中检测到牙周病原体和需氧革兰氏阴性菌,而金黄色葡萄球菌和念珠菌仅在少数样本中鉴定到。污染率基本不受时间点、设备或使用方式的影响。此外,更换喷嘴并不能防止污染水射流的传播,但深度清洁显著降低了大多数病原体,除变形链球菌外。
无论使用方式如何,亦或更换喷嘴,都不能防止 SAF/SAFU 水射流中的细菌定植和生物膜成分的传播。
电动冲牙器中的细菌定植似乎无法预防;为了限制家庭内的交叉污染风险,建议每人使用一个设备。