Mgbemena Okechukwu N, Sears Isaac, Levine Barry
Cardiology, University of Florida, Jacksonville, USA.
Medicine, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, USA.
Cureus. 2021 Aug 27;13(8):e17483. doi: 10.7759/cureus.17483. eCollection 2021 Aug.
Background A critical decrease in the number of healthcare providers in developing countries is one of the major burdens to healthcare access in these countries. Many factors contribute to the lack of healthcare providers, including low doctor-to-population ratio, emigration of doctors to other countries, long travel distances to hospitals, increasing cost of healthcare, and concentration of doctors in urban cities. Several measures have been taken by both governmental and nongovernmental organizations in these countries to mitigate this crisis with varying outcomes. In this study, we investigate the use of technology in the form of telemedicine in a developing country. We evaluate patient predisposition to the use of telemedicine, their experience, and some challenges involved in the use of telemedicine in this setting. Methodology We set up an electronic medical record system, OpenMRS, and added telemedicine modules to the system. Then, we recruited doctors and gave them privileges on OpenMRS after carefully vetting their credentials. Finally, we set up a website through which patients could request telemedicine consultations. We registered a telephone number in Nigeria so that patients could also request consultations via SMS. Consult requests were then entered into OpenMRS. Doctors logged in periodically and checked for patients awaiting consults. They called patients, diagnosed them, requested further diagnostics, and/or sent prescriptions to patients via SMS directly from OpenMRS. Results Data were collected over the first year of telemedicine service in Nigeria. These data were then analyzed to understand the effectiveness, patient experience, cost efficiency, and general utilization of this service. In the first year, there were 510 new patient registrations and 572 total consultations. Patient age ranged from less than one year to 77 years, with a median of 29 years. Among the users of the service, 51.8% (264) were female. For consult requests, 52.2% of requests were via the web, and others were via SMS requests. There were over 50 reviews of the service on the website and social media, and 95% of users reported a positive experience. Conclusions From preliminary data, telemedicine can potentially be a good adjunct to help doctors reach their patients, especially in rural areas where there is an immense shortage of healthcare professions. Although most patients reported a positive experience, further investigations are needed to validate our experience.
发展中国家医疗服务提供者数量的急剧减少是这些国家医疗服务可及性面临的主要负担之一。导致医疗服务提供者短缺的因素众多,包括医生与人口比例低、医生移民到其他国家、到医院的路途遥远、医疗成本不断增加以及医生集中在城市等。这些国家的政府和非政府组织已采取多项措施来缓解这一危机,但效果各异。在本研究中,我们调查了在一个发展中国家以远程医疗形式使用技术的情况。我们评估了患者对使用远程医疗的倾向、他们的体验以及在这种情况下使用远程医疗所涉及的一些挑战。
我们建立了一个电子病历系统OpenMRS,并在系统中添加了远程医疗模块。然后,我们招募医生,并在仔细审核他们的资质后给予他们在OpenMRS上的权限。最后,我们建立了一个网站,患者可以通过该网站请求远程医疗咨询。我们在尼日利亚注册了一个电话号码,以便患者也可以通过短信请求咨询。咨询请求随后被录入OpenMRS。医生定期登录并查看等待咨询的患者。他们给患者打电话,进行诊断,要求进一步诊断,和/或直接从OpenMRS通过短信给患者开处方。
在尼日利亚远程医疗服务的第一年收集了数据。然后对这些数据进行分析,以了解该服务的有效性、患者体验、成本效益和总体利用率。第一年,有510例新患者注册,共进行了572次咨询。患者年龄从不到1岁到77岁不等,中位数为29岁。在该服务的用户中,51.8%(264人)为女性。对于咨询请求,52.2%的请求是通过网络提出的,其他是通过短信请求。网站和社交媒体上有超过50条对该服务的评价,95%的用户报告有积极体验。
根据初步数据,远程医疗可能是帮助医生接触患者的良好辅助手段,特别是在医疗专业人员极度短缺的农村地区。尽管大多数患者报告有积极体验,但仍需要进一步调查来验证我们的经验。