Meleo-Erwin Zoe C, Basch Corey H, Fera Joseph, Smith Bonnie
Department of Public Health, William Paterson University of New Jersey, Wayne, NJ, United States.
Department of Mathematics, Lehman College, City University of New York, Bronx, NY, United States.
JMIR Perioper Med. 2021 Nov 1;4(2):e29390. doi: 10.2196/29390.
The majority of American adults search for health and illness information on the internet. However, the quality and accuracy of this information are notoriously variable. With the advent of social media, US individuals have increasingly shared their own health and illness experiences, including those related to bariatric surgery, on social media platforms. Previous research has found that peer-to-peer requesting and giving of advice related to bariatric surgery on social media is common, that such advice is often presented in stark terms, and that the advice may not reflect patient standards of care. These previous investigations have helped to map bariatric surgery content on Facebook and YouTube.
This objective of this study was to document and compare weight loss surgery (WLS)-related content on Instagram in the months leading up to the COVID-19 pandemic and 1 year later.
We analyzed a total of 300 Instagram posts (50 posts per week for 3 consecutive weeks in late February and early March in both 2020 and 2021) uploaded using the hashtag #wls. Descriptive statistics were reported, and independent 1-tailed chi-square tests were used to determine if a post's publication year statistically affected its inclusion of a particular type of content.
Overall, advice giving and personal responsibility for outcomes were emphasized by WLS posters on Instagram. However, social support was less emphasized. The safety, challenges, and risks associated with WLS were rarely discussed. The majority of posts did not contain references to facts from reputable medical sources. Posts published in 2021 were more likely to mention stress/hardships of living with WLS (45/150, 30%, vs 29/150, 19.3%; P=.03); however, those published in 2020 more often identified the importance of ongoing support for WLS success (35/150, 23.3%, vs 16/150, 10.7%; P=.004).
Given that bariatric patients have low rates of postoperative follow-up, yet post-operative care and yet support are associated with improved health and weight loss outcomes, and given that health content on the web is of mixed accuracy, bariatric professionals may wish to consider including an online support forum moderated by a professional as a routine part of postoperative care. Doing so may not only improve follow-up rates but may offer providers the opportunity to counter inaccuracies encountered on social media.
大多数美国成年人会在互联网上搜索健康与疾病信息。然而,这些信息的质量和准确性参差不齐,这是出了名的。随着社交媒体的出现,美国人越来越多地在社交媒体平台上分享自己的健康与疾病经历,包括与减肥手术相关的经历。此前的研究发现,在社交媒体上,关于减肥手术的点对点建议请求和提供很常见,这类建议往往表述直白,而且可能不符合患者的护理标准。这些先前的调查有助于梳理脸书和YouTube上的减肥手术相关内容。
本研究的目的是记录并比较在2019冠状病毒病大流行前几个月及一年后Instagram上与减肥手术(WLS)相关的内容。
我们分析了总共300条使用#wls标签上传的Instagram帖子(2020年和2021年2月下旬及3月初连续3周,每周50条帖子)。报告了描述性统计数据,并使用独立单尾卡方检验来确定帖子的发布年份是否在统计学上影响其对特定类型内容的包含情况。
总体而言,Instagram上减肥手术相关帖子强调了提供建议和对结果的个人责任。然而,社会支持较少被提及。与减肥手术相关的安全性、挑战和风险很少被讨论。大多数帖子没有引用来自可靠医学来源的事实。2021年发布的帖子更有可能提及减肥手术后生活的压力/艰辛(45/150,30%,对比29/150,19.3%;P = 0.03);然而,2020年发布的帖子更常指出持续支持对减肥手术成功的重要性(35/150,23.3%,对比16/150,10.7%;P = 0.004)。
鉴于减肥手术患者术后随访率较低,而术后护理及支持与改善健康和减肥效果相关,且鉴于网络上的健康内容准确性参差不齐,减肥手术专业人员不妨考虑将由专业人员主持的在线支持论坛作为术后护理的常规组成部分。这样做不仅可能提高随访率,还可能为医护人员提供机会来纠正社交媒体上出现的不准确信息。