Pallua Johannes, Schirmer Michael
University Hospital for Orthopedics and Traumatology, Medical University of Innsbruck, Innsbruck, Austria.
Fachhochschule Gesundheit, Health University of Applied Sciences Tyrol, Innsbruck, Austria.
Front Med (Lausanne). 2021 Oct 25;8:757102. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2021.757102. eCollection 2021.
While the use of the term "quality" in industry relates to the basic idea of making processes measurable and standardizing processes, medicine focuses on achieving health goals that go far beyond the mere implementation of diagnostic and therapeutic processes. However, the quality management systems used are often simple, self-created concepts that concentrate on administrative processes without considering the quality of the results, which is essential for the patient. For several rheumatic diseases, both outcome and treatment goals have been defined. This work summarizes current mainstreams of strategies with published quality efforts in rheumatology. PubMed, Cochrane Library, and Web of Science were used to search for studies, and additional manual searches were carried out. Screening and content evaluation were carried out using the PRISMA-P 2015 checklist. After duplicate search in the Endnote reference management software (version X9.1), the software Rayyan QCRI (https://rayyan.qcri.org) was applied to check for pre-defined inclusion and exclusion criteria. Abstracts and full texts were screened and rated using Voyant Tools (https://voyant-tools.org/). Key issues were identified using the collocate analysis. The number of selected publications was small but specific (14 relevant correlations with coefficients >0.8). Using trend analysis, 15 publications with relative frequency of keywords >0.0125 were used for content analysis, revealing 5 quality needs. The treat to target (T2T) initiative was identified as fundamental paradigm. Outcome parameters required for T2T also allow quality assessments in routine clinical work. Quality care by multidisciplinary teams also focusing on polypharmacy and other quality aspects become essential, A global software platform to assess quality aspects is missing. Such an approach requires reporting of multiple outcome parameters according to evidence-based clinical guidelines and recommendations for the different rheumatic diseases. All health aspects defined by the WHO (physical, mental, and social health) have to be integrated into the management of rheumatic patients. For the future, quality projects need goals defined by T2T based initiatives in routine clinical work, secondary quality goals include multidisciplinary cooperation and reduction of polypharmacy. Quality indicators and standards in different health systems will provide new information to optimize patients' care in different health systems.
虽然工业领域中“质量”一词的使用涉及使流程可衡量和标准化流程的基本理念,但医学关注的是实现远远超出单纯实施诊断和治疗流程的健康目标。然而,所使用的质量管理系统往往是简单的、自行创建的概念,专注于行政流程而不考虑对患者至关重要的结果质量。对于几种风湿性疾病,已经定义了结果和治疗目标。这项工作总结了风湿病学中已发表的质量努力的当前主流策略。使用PubMed、Cochrane图书馆和科学网搜索研究,并进行了额外的手动搜索。使用PRISMA - P 2015清单进行筛选和内容评估。在Endnote参考文献管理软件(版本X9.1)中进行重复搜索后,应用Rayyan QCRI软件(https://rayyan.qcri.org)检查预定义的纳入和排除标准。使用Voyant Tools(https://voyant-tools.org/)筛选和评级摘要及全文。使用搭配分析确定关键问题。所选出版物数量虽少但具有针对性(14个相关相关性,系数>0.8)。使用趋势分析,将15篇关键词相对频率>0.0125的出版物用于内容分析,揭示了5个质量需求。治疗到目标(T2T)倡议被确定为基本范式。T2T所需的结果参数也允许在日常临床工作中进行质量评估。多学科团队的优质护理,同时关注联合用药和其他质量方面变得至关重要,缺少一个评估质量方面的全球软件平台。这种方法需要根据针对不同风湿性疾病的循证临床指南和建议报告多个结果参数。世界卫生组织定义的所有健康方面(身体、心理和社会健康)都必须纳入风湿性患者的管理中。未来,质量项目需要在日常临床工作中基于T2T倡议定义目标,二级质量目标包括多学科合作和减少联合用药。不同卫生系统中的质量指标和标准将为优化不同卫生系统中患者的护理提供新信息。