Centre for Optometry and Vision Science, School of Biomedical Sciences, Ulster University, Coleraine, UK.
Ophthalmic Physiol Opt. 2022 Jan;42(1):48-58. doi: 10.1111/opo.12918. Epub 2021 Nov 10.
To evaluate the repeatability and reproducibility of the swept-source optical coherence tomographer Zeiss IOLMaster 700 and compare its outputs with those obtained using partial coherence interferometry (Zeiss IOLMaster v3) in a healthy, paediatric population.
This is a cross-sectional, observational study. Examiner 1 took two sets of biometric measurements (axial length [AL], mean corneal radius of curvature [K ], anterior chamber depth [ACD] and lens thickness [LT]) using the IOLMaster 700, and one set of measurements (AL, K and ACD) using the IOLMaster v3. Examiner 2 took one full set of measurements using the IOLMaster 700. Mean differences and 95% limits of agreement (LOA) were calculated, and Bland and Altman plots used to explore repeatability and reproducibility of the IOLMaster 700 alongside establishing its agreement with the IOLMaster v3.
Mean participant age was 7.52 ± 0.58 years. Repeatability analyses demonstrated small mean differences and narrow 95% LOA for AL (0.001, -0.013 to 0.015 mm), K (0.002, -0.020 to 0.024 mm), ACD (-0.003, -0.031 to 0.024 mm) and LT (0.001, -0.024 to 0.026 mm), respectively. Similarly, small mean differences and narrow 95% LOA established excellent reproducibility (AL 0.001, -0.016 to 0.018 mm; K -0.001, -0.027 to 0.025 mm; ACD -0.010, -0.041 to 0.021 mm; LT 0.002, -0.016 to 0.020 mm). The IOLMaster 700 and IOLMaster v3 demonstrated good agreement with small mean differences and narrow 95% LOA (AL 0.009, -0.034 to 0.052 mm; K 0.016, -0.013 to 0.044 mm; ACD 0.134, 0.055 to 0.212 mm).
When used within a paediatric population, these data demonstrate the IOLMaster 700 to be highly repeatable and reproducible for measures of AL, K , ACD and LT. There is excellent inter-instrument agreement between the IOLMaster 700 and IOLMaster v3 for measures of AL and K . ACD measurements show weaker agreement. These data will be useful when considering reports from population-based studies of refractive error and clinical myopia research.
评估扫频源光相干断层扫描仪 Zeiss IOLMaster 700 的重复性和再现性,并将其与使用部分相干干涉测量法(Zeiss IOLMaster v3)在健康的儿科人群中的结果进行比较。
这是一项横断面、观察性研究。检查者 1 使用 IOLMaster 700 进行两组生物测量(眼轴 [AL]、平均角膜曲率半径 [K]、前房深度 [ACD]和晶状体厚度 [LT]),并使用 IOLMaster v3 进行一组测量(AL、K 和 ACD)。检查者 2 使用 IOLMaster 700 进行一次完整的测量。计算平均差异和 95%的一致性界限(LOA),并使用 Bland 和 Altman 图来探讨 IOLMaster 700 的重复性和再现性,并确定其与 IOLMaster v3 的一致性。
平均参与者年龄为 7.52±0.58 岁。AL(0.001,-0.013 至 0.015 毫米)、K(0.002,-0.020 至 0.024 毫米)、ACD(-0.003,-0.031 至 0.024 毫米)和 LT(0.001,-0.024 至 0.026 毫米)的重复性分析显示出较小的平均差异和较窄的 95%LOA。同样,较小的平均差异和较窄的 95%LOA 建立了极好的再现性(AL 0.001,-0.016 至 0.018 毫米;K-0.001,-0.027 至 0.025 毫米;ACD-0.010,-0.041 至 0.021 毫米;LT 0.002,-0.016 至 0.020 毫米)。IOLMaster 700 和 IOLMaster v3 之间具有良好的一致性,差异较小,95%LOA 较窄(AL 0.009,-0.034 至 0.052 毫米;K 0.016,-0.013 至 0.044 毫米;ACD 0.134,0.055 至 0.212 毫米)。
在儿科人群中使用时,这些数据表明 IOLMaster 700 对 AL、K、ACD 和 LT 的测量具有高度的重复性和再现性。IOLMaster 700 和 IOLMaster v3 之间在 AL 和 K 的测量方面具有极好的仪器间一致性。ACD 测量的一致性稍差。这些数据在考虑基于人群的屈光不正研究和临床近视研究的报告时将非常有用。