Albahri A S, Alnoor Alhamzah, Zaidan A A, Albahri O S, Hameed Hamsa, Zaidan B B, Peh S S, Zain A B, Siraj S B, Masnan A H B, Yass A A
Faculty of Human Development, Sultan Idris University of Education (UPSI), Tanjung Malim, Malaysia.
Informatics Institute for Postgraduate, Studies (IIPS), Iraqi Commission for Computers and Informatics, Baghdad, Iraq.
Complex Intell Systems. 2022;8(2):1781-1801. doi: 10.1007/s40747-021-00503-w. Epub 2021 Aug 28.
Topical treatments with structural equation modelling (SEM) and an artificial neural network (ANN), including a wide range of concepts, benefits, challenges and anxieties, have emerged in various fields and are becoming increasingly important. Although SEM can determine relationships amongst unobserved constructs (i.e. independent, mediator, moderator, control and dependent variables), it is insufficient for providing non-compensatory relationships amongst constructs. In contrast with previous studies, a newly proposed methodology that involves a dual-stage analysis of SEM and ANN was performed to provide linear and non-compensatory relationships amongst constructs. Consequently, numerous distinct types of studies in diverse sectors have conducted hybrid SEM-ANN analysis. Accordingly, the current work supplements the academic literature with a systematic review that includes all major SEM-ANN techniques used in 11 industries published in the past 6 years. This study presents a state-of-the-art SEM-ANN classification taxonomy based on industries and compares the effort in various domains to that classification. To achieve this objective, we examined the Web of Science, ScienceDirect, Scopus and IEEE databases to retrieve 239 articles from 2016 to 2021. The obtained articles were filtered on the basis of inclusion criteria, and 60 studies were selected and classified under 11 categories. This multi-field systematic study uncovered new research possibilities, motivations, challenges, limitations and recommendations that must be addressed for the synergistic integration of multidisciplinary studies. It contributed two points of potential future work resulting from the developed taxonomy. First, the importance of the determinants of play, musical and art therapy adoption amongst autistic children within the healthcare sector is the most important consideration for future investigations. In this context, the second potential future work can use SEM-ANN to determine the barriers to adopting sensing-enhanced therapy amongst autistic children to satisfy the recommendations provided by the healthcare sector. The analysis indicates that the manufacturing and technology sectors have conducted the most number of investigations, whereas the construction and small- and medium-sized enterprise sectors have conducted the least. This study will provide a helpful reference to academics and practitioners by providing guidance and insightful knowledge for future studies.
运用结构方程模型(SEM)和人工神经网络(ANN)的局部治疗方法,涵盖了广泛的概念、益处、挑战和担忧,已在各个领域出现并变得愈发重要。尽管SEM能够确定未观察到的结构(即自变量、中介变量、调节变量、控制变量和因变量)之间的关系,但它不足以提供结构之间的非补偿关系。与先前的研究不同,一种新提出的涉及SEM和ANN双阶段分析的方法被用于提供结构之间的线性和非补偿关系。因此,不同领域的众多不同类型研究都进行了混合SEM - ANN分析。相应地,当前的工作通过系统综述补充了学术文献,该综述涵盖了过去6年在11个行业中使用的所有主要SEM - ANN技术。本研究基于行业提出了一种最新的SEM - ANN分类法,并将各个领域的研究成果与该分类法进行比较。为实现这一目标,我们查阅了科学网、ScienceDirect、Scopus和IEEE数据库,以检索2016年至2021年的239篇文章。所获取的文章根据纳入标准进行筛选,60项研究被选中并归类为11个类别。这项多领域系统研究揭示了多学科研究协同整合必须解决的新研究可能性、动机、挑战、局限性和建议。它从所制定的分类法中得出了两点潜在的未来工作方向。首先,医疗保健领域中自闭症儿童游戏、音乐和艺术治疗采用的决定因素的重要性是未来研究最重要的考虑因素。在此背景下,第二个潜在的未来工作方向可以利用SEM - ANN来确定自闭症儿童采用传感增强治疗的障碍,以满足医疗保健领域提供的建议。分析表明,制造业和技术领域进行的调查最多,而建筑和中小企业领域进行的调查最少。本研究将为学者和从业者提供有益的参考,为未来研究提供指导和有见地的知识。