Department of Anthropology, University of the Philippines Diliman, Philippines; Development Studies Program, Ateneo de Manila University, Philippines.
Development Studies Program, Ateneo de Manila University, Philippines; Social Medicine Unit, College of Medicine, University of the Philippines Manila, Philippines.
Soc Sci Med. 2022 Jan;292:114567. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2021.114567. Epub 2021 Nov 14.
As part of their populist performances during disease outbreaks, public officials and politicians tend to offer 'miracle cures' or 'wonder drugs' that can supposedly treat or prevent the disease in question. This article analyzes contemporary instances of what we call 'pharmaceutical messianism' and proposes four characteristics for this phenomenon, namely, that it: (1) emerges during times of extraordinary health crisis; (2) builds on pre-existing knowledge, practices, and sentiments; (3) borrows from medical, often heterodox, authority; and (4) involves accessible, affordable, and/or familiar substances. Demonstrating the analytic value of our framework, we present three case studies, constructed using academic and journalistic sources, during the COVID-19 pandemic: hydroxychloroquine in France, ivermectin in the Philippines, and Covid-Organics in Madagascar. We conclude by identifying some implications of our findings on public health and avenues for future research.
作为其在疾病爆发期间民粹主义表现的一部分,政府官员和政客往往会提供“神奇疗法”或“灵丹妙药”,据称可以治疗或预防相关疾病。本文分析了当代所谓的“药物救世主主义”实例,并为这一现象提出了四个特征,即:(1)出现在非常健康危机时期;(2)建立在预先存在的知识、实践和情绪基础上;(3)借鉴医学,通常是异端的权威;(4)涉及易于获得、负担得起和/或熟悉的物质。为了展示我们框架的分析价值,我们在 COVID-19 大流行期间使用学术和新闻来源构建了三个案例研究:法国的羟氯喹、菲律宾的伊维菌素和马达加斯加的 Covid-Organics。最后,我们确定了我们的研究结果对公共卫生的一些影响和未来研究的途径。