Center for Population Health Informatics, Institute for Informatics, Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis, Saint Louis, MO, United States.
Department of Medicine, Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis, Saint Louis, MO, United States.
JMIR Public Health Surveill. 2021 Dec 15;7(12):e33617. doi: 10.2196/33617.
The COVID-19 (the disease caused by the SARS-CoV-2 virus) pandemic has underscored the need for additional data, tools, and methods that can be used to combat emerging and existing public health concerns. Since March 2020, there has been substantial interest in using social media data to both understand and intervene in the pandemic. Researchers from many disciplines have recently found a relationship between COVID-19 and a new data set from Facebook called the Social Connectedness Index (SCI).
Building off this work, we seek to use the SCI to examine how social similarity of Missouri counties could explain similarities of COVID-19 cases over time. Additionally, we aim to add to the body of literature on the utility of the SCI by using a novel modeling technique.
In September 2020, we conducted this cross-sectional study using publicly available data to test the association between the SCI and COVID-19 spread in Missouri using exponential random graph models, which model relational data, and the outcome variable must be binary, representing the presence or absence of a relationship. In our model, this was the presence or absence of a highly correlated COVID-19 case count trajectory between two given counties in Missouri. Covariates included each county's total population, percent rurality, and distance between each county pair.
We found that all covariates were significantly associated with two counties having highly correlated COVID-19 case count trajectories. As the log of a county's total population increased, the odds of two counties having highly correlated COVID-19 case count trajectories increased by 66% (odds ratio [OR] 1.66, 95% CI 1.43-1.92). As the percent of a county classified as rural increased, the odds of two counties having highly correlated COVID-19 case count trajectories increased by 1% (OR 1.01, 95% CI 1.00-1.01). As the distance (in miles) between two counties increased, the odds of two counties having highly correlated COVID-19 case count trajectories decreased by 43% (OR 0.57, 95% CI 0.43-0.77). Lastly, as the log of the SCI between two Missouri counties increased, the odds of those two counties having highly correlated COVID-19 case count trajectories significantly increased by 17% (OR 1.17, 95% CI 1.09-1.26).
These results could suggest that two counties with a greater likelihood of sharing Facebook friendships means residents of those counties have a higher likelihood of sharing similar belief systems, in particular as they relate to COVID-19 and public health practices. Another possibility is that the SCI is picking up travel or movement data among county residents. This suggests the SCI is capturing a unique phenomenon relevant to COVID-19 and that it may be worth adding to other COVID-19 models. Additional research is needed to better understand what the SCI is capturing practically and what it means for public health policies and prevention practices.
COVID-19(由 SARS-CoV-2 病毒引起的疾病)大流行凸显了需要额外的数据、工具和方法,以应对新出现和现有的公共卫生问题。自 2020 年 3 月以来,人们对利用社交媒体数据来理解和干预大流行产生了浓厚的兴趣。最近,来自多个学科的研究人员发现 COVID-19 与 Facebook 提供的一个名为社交关联指数(SCI)的新数据集之间存在关系。
在此基础上,我们试图利用 SCI 来研究密苏里州各县之间的社会相似性如何解释随时间推移 COVID-19 病例的相似性。此外,我们旨在通过使用一种新的建模技术来增加关于 SCI 实用性的文献。
2020 年 9 月,我们使用公开数据进行了这项横断面研究,使用指数随机图模型检验 SCI 与密苏里州 COVID-19 传播之间的关联,该模型用于建模关系数据,且结果变量必须是二进制的,表示存在或不存在关系。在我们的模型中,这是两个密苏里州的给定县之间存在或不存在高度相关的 COVID-19 病例计数轨迹。协变量包括每个县的总人口、农村人口比例和每对县之间的距离。
我们发现所有协变量都与两个县具有高度相关的 COVID-19 病例计数轨迹显著相关。随着一个县总人口的对数增加,两个县具有高度相关的 COVID-19 病例计数轨迹的可能性增加了 66%(比值比 [OR] 1.66,95%CI 1.43-1.92)。随着一个县被归类为农村的比例增加,两个县具有高度相关的 COVID-19 病例计数轨迹的可能性增加了 1%(OR 1.01,95%CI 1.00-1.01)。随着两个县之间的距离(英里)增加,两个县具有高度相关的 COVID-19 病例计数轨迹的可能性降低了 43%(OR 0.57,95%CI 0.43-0.77)。最后,随着两个密苏里州之间的 SCI 对数增加,这两个县具有高度相关的 COVID-19 病例计数轨迹的可能性显著增加了 17%(OR 1.17,95%CI 1.09-1.26)。
这些结果可能表明,具有更高共享 Facebook 好友可能性的两个县意味着这些县的居民更有可能共享相似的信仰体系,特别是在 COVID-19 和公共卫生实践方面。另一种可能性是,SCI 正在捕捉县居民之间的旅行或移动数据。这表明 SCI 正在捕捉与 COVID-19 相关的独特现象,并且可能值得添加到其他 COVID-19 模型中。需要进一步研究以更好地了解 SCI 在实践中捕捉到了什么,以及它对公共卫生政策和预防措施意味着什么。