Rainey Clare, O'Regan Tracy, Matthew Jacqueline, Skelton Emily, Woznitza Nick, Chu Kwun-Ye, Goodman Spencer, McConnell Jonathan, Hughes Ciara, Bond Raymond, McFadden Sonyia, Malamateniou Christina
Faculty of Life and Health Sciences, School of Health Sciences, Ulster University, Newtownabbey, United Kingdom.
The Society and College of Radiographers, London, United Kingdom.
Front Digit Health. 2021 Nov 11;3:739327. doi: 10.3389/fdgth.2021.739327. eCollection 2021.
The use of artificial intelligence (AI) in medical imaging and radiotherapy has been met with both scepticism and excitement. However, clinical integration of AI is already well-underway. Many authors have recently reported on the AI knowledge and perceptions of radiologists/medical staff and students however there is a paucity of information regarding radiographers. Published literature agrees that AI is likely to have significant impact on radiology practice. As radiographers are at the forefront of radiology service delivery, an awareness of the current level of their perceived knowledge, skills, and confidence in AI is essential to identify any educational needs necessary for successful adoption into practice. The aim of this survey was to determine the perceived knowledge, skills, and confidence in AI amongst UK radiographers and highlight priorities for educational provisions to support a digital healthcare ecosystem. A survey was created on Qualtrics® and promoted via social media (Twitter®/LinkedIn®). This survey was open to all UK radiographers, including students and retired radiographers. Participants were recruited by convenience, snowball sampling. Demographic information was gathered as well as data on the perceived, self-reported, knowledge, skills, and confidence in AI of respondents. Insight into what the participants understand by the term "AI" was gained by means of a free text response. Quantitative analysis was performed using SPSS® and qualitative thematic analysis was performed on NVivo®. Four hundred and eleven responses were collected (80% from diagnostic radiography and 20% from a radiotherapy background), broadly representative of the workforce distribution in the UK. Although many respondents stated that they understood the concept of AI in general (78.7% for diagnostic and 52.1% for therapeutic radiography respondents, respectively) there was a notable lack of sufficient knowledge of AI principles, understanding of AI terminology, skills, and confidence in the use of AI technology. Many participants, 57% of diagnostic and 49% radiotherapy respondents, do not feel adequately trained to implement AI in the clinical setting. Furthermore 52% and 64%, respectively, said they have not developed any skill in AI whilst 62% and 55%, respectively, stated that there is not enough AI training for radiographers. The majority of the respondents indicate that there is an urgent need for further education (77.4% of diagnostic and 73.9% of therapeutic radiographers feeling they have not had adequate training in AI), with many respondents stating that they had to educate themselves to gain some basic AI skills. Notable correlations between confidence in working with AI and gender, age, and highest qualification were reported. Knowledge of AI terminology, principles, and applications by healthcare practitioners is necessary for adoption and integration of AI applications. The results of this survey highlight the perceived lack of knowledge, skills, and confidence for radiographers in applying AI solutions but also underline the need for formalised education on AI to prepare the current and prospective workforce for the upcoming clinical integration of AI in healthcare, to safely and efficiently navigate a digital future. Focus should be given on different needs of learners depending on age, gender, and highest qualification to ensure optimal integration.
人工智能(AI)在医学成像和放射治疗中的应用既引发了怀疑,也带来了兴奋之情。然而,AI的临床整合已经在顺利进行。最近,许多作者报道了放射科医生/医务人员和学生对AI的了解及看法,然而关于放射技师的信息却很匮乏。已发表的文献一致认为,AI可能会对放射学实践产生重大影响。由于放射技师处于放射学服务提供的前沿,了解他们目前对AI的认知水平、技能和信心,对于确定成功应用于实践所需的任何教育需求至关重要。本次调查的目的是确定英国放射技师对AI的认知、技能和信心,并突出教育 provision 的重点,以支持数字医疗生态系统。在Qualtrics®上创建了一项调查,并通过社交媒体(Twitter®/LinkedIn®)进行推广。该调查面向所有英国放射技师,包括学生和退休放射技师。参与者通过便利抽样和滚雪球抽样的方式招募。收集了人口统计学信息以及关于受访者对AI的认知、自我报告的知识、技能和信心的数据。通过自由文本回复,了解了参与者对“AI”一词的理解。使用SPSS®进行定量分析,使用NVivo®进行定性主题分析。共收集到411份回复(80%来自诊断放射学,20%来自放射治疗背景),大致代表了英国劳动力的分布情况。尽管许多受访者表示他们总体上理解AI的概念(诊断放射学受访者中分别为78.7%,治疗放射学受访者中为52.1%),但对AI原理的了解明显不足,对AI术语的理解、技能以及对使用AI技术的信心也不足。许多参与者,诊断放射学受访者中的57%和放射治疗受访者中的49%,认为自己没有接受足够的培训以在临床环境中应用AI。此外,分别有52%和64%的人表示他们没有培养任何AI技能,而分别有62%和55%的人表示针对放射技师的AI培训不足。大多数受访者表示迫切需要进一步教育(诊断放射学受访者中的77.4%和治疗放射学受访者中的73.9%认为他们没有接受足够的AI培训),许多受访者表示他们不得不自学以获得一些基本的AI技能。报告了在使用AI方面的信心与性别、年龄和最高学历之间的显著相关性。医疗从业者对AI术语、原理和应用的了解对于采用和整合AI应用是必要的。本次调查的结果凸显了放射技师在应用AI解决方案方面认知、技能和信心的不足,但也强调了对AI进行正规教育的必要性,以便为当前和未来的劳动力做好准备,迎接即将到来的AI在医疗保健中的临床整合,安全有效地驾驭数字未来。应根据年龄、性别和最高学历关注学习者的不同需求,以确保最佳整合。