HLA-DR4 in insulin-dependent diabetic parents and their diabetic offspring: a clue to dominant inheritance.

Insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) susceptibility determinants are known to be associated with both HLA-DR3 and -DR4. We monitored the inheritance of HLA-DR alleles in 37 families in which IDDM affected one parent and at least one offspring in order to try to learn more about the modes of inheritance of IDDM determinants. Ninety-seven insulin-dependent diabetics whose parents did not have diabetes and 158 nondiabetics were used as control groups for estimates of DR allele frequencies in the overall diabetic and general populations. The proportion of diabetic parents who transmitted DR4 to diabetic offspring (78%) was significantly higher (P less than 0.001) than the gene frequency of DR4 in the overall diabetic population (43%). The proportion of nondiabetic parents who transmitted DR4 to diabetic offspring (22%) was not significantly different from the gene frequency of DR4 in the nondiabetic population (16%), but it was significantly lower (P less than 0.05) than the gene frequency in the overall IDDM population. These proportions suggest that inheritance of the DR4-associated IDDM susceptibility determinant is not recessive, because in recessive inheritance expression of a trait depends on each parent contributing a susceptibility determinant. The proportions of diabetic and nondiabetic parents who transmitted the DR allele associated with the susceptibility determinant would then equal one another. The transmission of predominantly DR4 from affected parents to affected offspring suggests that susceptibility to IDDM is inherited primarily via a single dose of a potent determinant associated with DR4, as in dominant inheritance. When DR3 was transmitted at all it was usually by the nondiabetic parent. Only 8% of diabetic parents transmitted DR3 but 35% of nondiabetic parents transmitted DR3. The proportion of nondiabetic parents who transmitted DR3 was similar to the gene frequency of DR3 in the overall diabetic population (29%), but it was significantly higher than the gene frequency of DR3 in the nondiabetic population (15%; P less than 0.005). The percentage of diabetic offspring with the genotype DR3DR4 (35%) was identical to the percentage of individuals in the overall IDDM population with this genotype (35%). Numerous population data indicate that the DR3DR4 genotype carries a higher relative risk for IDDM than any other genotype, which suggests synergism between the DR3- and DR4-associated determinants. The family data reported here support this synergism but suggest that the DR4-associated determinant can give substantial susceptibility independent of the DR3-associated determinant and that the DR3-associated determinant is often expressed as enhancing susceptibility in the presence of the dominant DR4- associated determinant.