Kieffer Emily E, Brolinson Per Gunnar, Maerlender Arthur E, Smith Eric P, Rowson Steven
School of Biomedical Engineering and Sciences and Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA.
Edward Via College of Osteopathic Medicine, Blacksburg, Virginia, USA.
Neurotrauma Rep. 2021 Nov 16;2(1):503-511. doi: 10.1089/neur.2021.0050. eCollection 2021.
Symptom inventories are generally only collected after a suspected concussion, but regular in-season monitoring may allude to clinical symptoms associated with repetitive subconcussive impacts and potential undiagnosed concussions. Despite sex-specific differences in symptom presentation and outcome of concussion, no return-to-play protocol takes sex into account. The objective of this study was to monitor a cohort of contact-sport athletes and compare the frequency and severity of in-season concussion-like symptom reporting between sexes. Graded symptom checklists from 144 female and 104 male athlete-seasons were administered weekly to quantify the effect of subconcussive impacts on frequency and severity of in-season symptom reporting. In-season, mean symptom severity score (SSS) ( = 0.026, mean difference of 1.8), mean number of symptoms ( = 0.044, mean difference of 0.9), max SSS ( < 0.001, mean difference of 19.2), and max number of symptoms ( < 0.001, mean difference of 6.8) were higher in the females. The females' survey results showed differences between elevated and concussed SSS ( < 0.005, mean difference of 28.1) and number of symptoms reported ( = 0.001, mean difference of 6.6). The males did not have a difference in SSS ( = 0.97, mean difference of 1.12) nor in number of symptoms ( = 0.35, mean difference of 1.96) from elevated to concussed athletes. Rugby players report concussion-like symptoms in the absence of a diagnosed concussion in-season. Female athletes reported elevated symptom frequencies with greater severities than the males, but both sexes reported considerable levels throughout the season.
症状清单通常仅在疑似脑震荡后收集,但赛季期间的定期监测可能会提示与重复性轻度脑震荡影响和潜在未诊断脑震荡相关的临床症状。尽管脑震荡的症状表现和结果存在性别差异,但没有任何重返赛场的方案考虑到性别因素。本研究的目的是监测一组接触性运动运动员,并比较男女在赛季期间类似脑震荡症状报告的频率和严重程度。每周对144个女性运动员赛季和104个男性运动员赛季进行分级症状清单评估,以量化轻度脑震荡影响对赛季期间症状报告频率和严重程度的影响。在赛季期间,女性的平均症状严重程度评分(SSS)(=0.026,平均差异为1.8)、平均症状数量(=0.044,平均差异为0.9)、最高SSS(<0.001,平均差异为19.2)和最高症状数量(<0.001,平均差异为6.8)更高。女性的调查结果显示,升高的SSS与脑震荡的SSS之间存在差异(<0.005,平均差异为28.1)以及报告的症状数量之间存在差异(=0.001,平均差异为6.6)。从症状升高到脑震荡的运动员,男性的SSS(=0.97,平均差异为1.12)和症状数量(=0.35,平均差异为1.96)均无差异。橄榄球运动员在赛季中未被诊断为脑震荡的情况下报告了类似脑震荡的症状。女运动员报告的症状频率升高且严重程度高于男运动员,但男女在整个赛季都报告了相当程度的症状。