Alcoba Gabriel, Potet Julien, Vatrinet Renaud, Singh Saschveen, Nanclares Carolina, Kruse Alexandra, Den Boer Margriet, Molfino Lucas, Ritmeijer Koert
Médecins Sans Frontières, Operational Center Geneva, Geneva, Switzerland.
Division of Tropical and Humanitarian Medicine, Geneva University Hospitals , Geneva, Switzerland.
Toxicon X. 2021 Dec 18;13:100089. doi: 10.1016/j.toxcx.2021.100089. eCollection 2022 Mar.
Snakebite envenoming is a public health concern in many countries affected by humanitarian crises. Its magnitude was recognized internationally but associations between snakebite peaks and humanitarian crises were never clearly established or analysed. This scoping review searched any available evidence of this hypothesized association between snakebite types of crises, through PubMed/Medline by two researchers. The search also included hand searching, and reports from humanitarian organizations working in this area. The scoping review yielded 41 results. None described a robust epidemiological link or evidence of causality. There is an evidence gap regarding our research question. Several publications however point or hint towards the occurrence of snakebite outbreaks during conflict, displacement, floods, and migration of impoverished agricultural workers. Non-systematic screening yielded another 11 publications (52 in total). We found Médecins Sans Frontières routine reports showing that 6469 patients were admitted in 2019 throughout its projects in 17 countries. The impact of snakebite was the highest in four countries particularly affected by humanitarian crises, South Sudan, Ethiopia, Central African Republic, and Yemen, with some hospitals receiving more than 1000 annual admissions. Time correlations with conflict and events are shown in Figures. We found no published epidemiological data formally showing any associations between humanitarian crises and snakebite incidence. However, the search publications showing peaks during crises, and monitoring curves in four countries point towards an increased risk during humanitarian crises. We call for urgent population-based studies and surveillance. Stakeholders should consider upgrading snakebite care and antivenom supply during humanitarian crises in snakebite-endemic countries.
蛇咬伤中毒是许多受人道主义危机影响国家的公共卫生问题。其严重程度已得到国际认可,但蛇咬伤高峰与人道主义危机之间的关联从未得到明确确立或分析。这项范围综述由两名研究人员通过PubMed/Medline搜索关于这种假设的蛇咬伤类型与危机之间关联的任何现有证据。搜索还包括手工检索以及在该领域工作的人道主义组织的报告。范围综述产生了41个结果。没有一个描述了强有力的流行病学联系或因果关系证据。关于我们的研究问题存在证据空白。然而,一些出版物指出或暗示在冲突、流离失所、洪水以及贫困农业工人迁移期间会发生蛇咬伤疫情。非系统性筛选又产生了11篇出版物(总共52篇)。我们发现无国界医生组织的常规报告显示,2019年在其17个国家的项目中共有6469名患者入院。蛇咬伤影响在四个特别受人道主义危机影响的国家最高,即南苏丹、埃塞俄比亚、中非共和国和也门,一些医院每年接收超过1000名患者入院。图中显示了与冲突和事件的时间相关性。我们没有找到正式显示人道主义危机与蛇咬伤发病率之间任何关联的已发表流行病学数据。然而,搜索到的显示危机期间高峰的出版物以及四个国家的监测曲线表明在人道主义危机期间风险增加。我们呼吁开展基于人群的紧急研究和监测。利益相关者应考虑在蛇咬伤流行国家的人道主义危机期间提升蛇咬伤护理和抗蛇毒血清供应。