Hebinck Aniek, Diercks Gijs, von Wirth Timo, Beers P J, Barsties Lisa, Buchel Sophie, Greer Rachel, van Steenbergen Frank, Loorbach Derk
Dutch Research Institute for Transitions (DRIFT), Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Erasmus School of Social and Behavioural Sciences (ESSB), Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Sustain Sci. 2022;17(3):1009-1021. doi: 10.1007/s11625-021-01084-w. Epub 2022 Jan 18.
Sustainability transition research seeks to understand the patterns and dynamics of structural societal change as well as unearth strategies for governance. However, existing frameworks emphasize innovation and build-up over exnovation and break-down. This limits their potential in making sense of the turbulent and chaotic dynamics of current transition-in-the-making. Addressing this gap, our paper elaborates on the development and use of the X-curve framework. The X-curve provides a simplified depiction of transitions that explicitly captures the patterns of build-up, breakdown, and their interactions. Using three cases, we illustrate the X-curve's main strength as a framework that can support groups of people to develop a shared understanding of the dynamics in transitions-in-the-making. This helps them reflect upon their roles, potential influence, and the needed capacities for desired transitions. We discuss some challenges in using the X-curve framework, such as participants' grasp of 'chaos', and provide suggestions on how to address these challenges and strengthen the frameworks' ability to support understanding and navigation of transition dynamics. We conclude by summarizing its main strength and invite the reader to use it, reflect on it, build on it, and judge its value for action research on sustainability transitions themselves.
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s11625-021-01084-w.
可持续性转型研究旨在理解结构性社会变革的模式和动态,并挖掘治理策略。然而,现有框架强调创新和积累,而非破旧和瓦解。这限制了它们在理解当前正在进行的转型的动荡和混沌动态方面的潜力。为弥补这一差距,我们的论文详细阐述了X曲线框架的发展和应用。X曲线提供了一种对转型的简化描述,明确捕捉了积累、瓦解及其相互作用的模式。通过三个案例,我们展示了X曲线作为一个框架的主要优势,它能够帮助人们形成对正在进行的转型动态的共同理解。这有助于他们反思自己的角色、潜在影响以及实现期望转型所需的能力。我们讨论了使用X曲线框架时的一些挑战,如参与者对“混沌”的理解,并就如何应对这些挑战以及增强该框架支持理解和驾驭转型动态的能力提供了建议。我们通过总结其主要优势得出结论,并邀请读者使用它、反思它、在此基础上进行拓展,并评判其对可持续性转型行动研究的价值。
在线版本包含可在10.1007/s11625-021-01084-w获取的补充材料。