Department of Clinical Neurosciences, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK.
Department of Neuroscience and Neuromuscular Disorders Centre, The Cyprus Institute of Neurology and Genetics, Nicosia, Cyprus.
Brain. 2022 Nov 21;145(11):3999-4015. doi: 10.1093/brain/awac055.
Molecular markers scalable for clinical use are critical for the development of effective treatments and the design of clinical trials. Here, we identify proteins in sera of patients and mouse models with Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT) with characteristics that make them suitable as biomarkers in clinical practice and therapeutic trials. We collected serum from mouse models of CMT1A (C61 het), CMT2D (GarsC201R, GarsP278KY), CMT1X (Gjb1-null), CMT2L (Hspb8K141N) and from CMT patients with genotypes including CMT1A (PMP22d), CMT2D (GARS), CMT2N (AARS) and other rare genetic forms of CMT. The severity of neuropathy in the patients was assessed by the CMT Neuropathy Examination Score (CMTES). We performed multitargeted proteomics on both sample sets to identify proteins elevated across multiple mouse models and CMT patients. Selected proteins and additional potential biomarkers, such as growth differentiation factor 15 (GDF15) and cell free mitochondrial DNA, were validated by ELISA and quantitative PCR, respectively. We propose that neural cell adhesion molecule 1 (NCAM1) is a candidate biomarker for CMT, as it was elevated in Gjb1-null, Hspb8K141N, GarsC201R and GarsP278KY mice as well as in patients with both demyelinating (CMT1A) and axonal (CMT2D, CMT2N) forms of CMT. We show that NCAM1 may reflect disease severity, demonstrated by a progressive increase in mouse models with time and a significant positive correlation with CMTES neuropathy severity in patients. The increase in NCAM1 may reflect muscle regeneration triggered by denervation, which could potentially track disease progression or the effect of treatments. We found that member proteins of the complement system were elevated in Gjb1-null and Hspb8K141N mouse models as well as in patients with both demyelinating and axonal CMT, indicating possible complement activation at the impaired nerve terminals. However, complement proteins did not correlate with the severity of neuropathy measured on the CMTES scale. Although the complement system does not seem to be a prognostic biomarker, we do show complement elevation to be a common disease feature of CMT, which may be of interest as a therapeutic target. We also identify serum GDF15 as a highly sensitive diagnostic biomarker, which was elevated in all CMT genotypes as well as in Hspb8K141N, Gjb1-null, GarsC201R and GarsP278KY mouse models. Although we cannot fully explain its origin, it may reflect increased stress response or metabolic disturbances in CMT. Further large and longitudinal patient studies should be performed to establish the value of these proteins as diagnostic and prognostic molecular biomarkers for CMT.
用于临床的可扩展分子标志物对于开发有效的治疗方法和设计临床试验至关重要。在这里,我们鉴定了患有遗传性周围神经病(CMT)的患者和小鼠模型血清中的蛋白质,这些蛋白质具有成为临床实践和治疗试验中生物标志物的特征。我们收集了 CMT1A(C61 het)、CMT2D(GarsC201R、GarsP278KY)、CMT1X(Gjb1-null)、CMT2L(Hspb8K141N)的小鼠模型以及 CMT1A(PMP22d)、CMT2D(GARS)、CMT2N(AARS)和其他罕见遗传形式 CMT 的患者的血清。患者的周围神经病严重程度通过 CMT 神经病变检查评分(CMTES)进行评估。我们对两组样本进行了多靶蛋白组学分析,以鉴定在多种小鼠模型和 CMT 患者中升高的蛋白质。通过 ELISA 和定量 PCR 分别验证了选定的蛋白质和其他潜在的生物标志物,如生长分化因子 15(GDF15)和无细胞线粒体 DNA。我们提出神经细胞黏附分子 1(NCAM1)是 CMT 的候选生物标志物,因为它在 Gjb1-null、Hspb8K141N、GarsC201R 和 GarsP278KY 小鼠以及脱髓鞘(CMT1A)和轴索(CMT2D、CMT2N)形式的 CMT 患者中均升高。我们表明,NCAM1 可能反映疾病的严重程度,这在随时间推移的小鼠模型中逐渐增加,并且与患者 CMTES 神经病变严重程度呈显著正相关。NCAM1 的增加可能反映了失神经支配引发的肌肉再生,这可能潜在地跟踪疾病进展或治疗效果。我们发现,补体系统的成员蛋白在 Gjb1-null 和 Hspb8K141N 小鼠模型以及脱髓鞘和轴索 CMT 的患者中均升高,表明受损神经末梢可能存在补体激活。然而,补体蛋白与 CMTES 量表上测量的神经病变严重程度没有相关性。尽管补体系统似乎不是预后生物标志物,但我们确实表明补体升高是 CMT 的共同疾病特征,这可能作为治疗靶点具有重要意义。我们还鉴定了血清 GDF15 作为一种高度敏感的诊断生物标志物,它在所有 CMT 基因型以及 Hspb8K141N、Gjb1-null、GarsC201R 和 GarsP278KY 小鼠模型中均升高。尽管我们无法完全解释其来源,但它可能反映了 CMT 中应激反应或代谢紊乱的增加。应进一步进行大型和纵向患者研究,以确定这些蛋白质作为 CMT 诊断和预后分子生物标志物的价值。