Voynova Elisaveta, Hawk Nga, Flomerfelt Francis A, Telford William G, Gress Ronald E, Kanakry Jennifer A, Kovalovsky Damian
Experimental Transplantation and Immunotherapy Branch, Center for Cancer Research, National Cancer Institute, NIH, Bethesda, MD 20892, USA.
Cancers (Basel). 2022 Jan 21;14(3):524. doi: 10.3390/cancers14030524.
NK effector cells expressing a CAR construct may be used to target T-lineage markers. In this work, we compared the activity of a NK-specific CAR-NK and a CAR-T framework when expressed on NK effector cells to target CD3 and CD5 in T-cell malignancies. Our results show that CD3-CAR-T is more active than CD5-CAR-T to eliminate malignant T cells in vitro, however, CD3-CAR-T were less efficient to eliminate tumor cells in vivo, while CD5-CAR-T had antitumor activity in a diffuse xenograft model. Lack of in vivo efficacy correlated with downregulation of CD3 levels in target T cells after coculture with CD3-CAR effector cells. The CAR-NK framework greatly improved the efficacy of CARs leading to increased degranulation, cytokine secretion and elimination of the tumor xenograft by CD5-CAR-NK effector cells. Finally, all CAR constructs were similarly effective to eliminate malignant T cells in vitro. Our results show that the NK-CAR framework improves the activity of CARs in NK cells and that CD5 would be a better target than CD3 for T-cell malignancies, as dynamic downregulation of target expression may affect in vivo efficacy.
表达嵌合抗原受体(CAR)构建体的自然杀伤(NK)效应细胞可用于靶向T细胞系标志物。在这项研究中,我们比较了在NK效应细胞上表达以靶向T细胞恶性肿瘤中的CD3和CD5时,NK特异性CAR-NK和CAR-T框架的活性。我们的结果表明,在体外消除恶性T细胞方面,CD3-CAR-T比CD5-CAR-T更具活性,然而,CD3-CAR-T在体内消除肿瘤细胞的效率较低,而CD5-CAR-T在弥漫性异种移植模型中具有抗肿瘤活性。体内疗效的缺乏与CD3-CAR效应细胞共培养后靶T细胞中CD3水平的下调相关。CAR-NK框架极大地提高了CAR的疗效,导致CD5-CAR-NK效应细胞的脱颗粒增加、细胞因子分泌增加以及肿瘤异种移植的消除。最后,所有CAR构建体在体外消除恶性T细胞方面同样有效。我们的结果表明,NK-CAR框架提高了CAR在NK细胞中的活性,并且对于T细胞恶性肿瘤,CD5可能是比CD3更好的靶点,因为靶标表达的动态下调可能影响体内疗效。