Kim Joeun, Luke Nancy
Department of Sociology and Criminology, The Pennsylvania State University, 512 Oswald Tower, University Park, PA 16802.
Department of Sociology and Criminology, The Pennsylvania State University, 702 Oswald Tower, University Park, PA 16802.
J Marriage Fam. 2020 Jun;82(3):1026-1040. doi: 10.1111/jomf.12615. Epub 2019 Oct 25.
This study investigates the association between men's economic dependency during midlife and allostatic load, an indicator of chronic stress, and how this relationship varies with men's gender ideology.
Women are primary breadwinners in almost a third of heterosexual couples in the U.S. Emerging research finds that female primary breadwinning (or men's economic dependency) is a threat to masculinity that has negative implications for men's midlife health. However, there is no quantitative evidence of the mechanisms linking men's economic dependency and health, particularly the role of stress, and whether men's gender ideology moderates this relationship.
Using two waves of Midlife in the United State (MIDUS) data for men who remained with the same marital or cohabiting female partner between waves (n = ), the authors estimate the relationship between men's economic dependency in wave 1 and allostatic load in wave 2.
There was no evidence of an association between men's economic dependency and higher allostatic load on average. However, gender ideology had a moderating influence; men's economic dependency was associated with higher allostatic load for those who espoused more traditional gender attitudes and lower allostatic load for those with the most egalitarian attitudes.
The findings underscore the existence of multiple masculinities and suggest that economic dependence has a negative or positive influence on men's health depending on the meanings men attach to female primary breadwinning.
本研究调查中年男性的经济依赖与慢性应激指标——累积生理失调负荷之间的关联,以及这种关系如何随男性的性别意识形态而变化。
在美国,近三分之一的异性恋夫妇中女性是主要经济支柱。新出现的研究发现,女性作为主要经济支柱(或男性的经济依赖)对男性气概构成威胁,对男性中年健康有负面影响。然而,尚无定量证据证明男性经济依赖与健康之间的关联机制,尤其是压力的作用,以及男性的性别意识形态是否会调节这种关系。
利用两轮美国中年(MIDUS)数据,针对两轮调查之间与同一婚姻或同居女性伴侣保持关系的男性(n = ),作者估算了第一轮调查中男性的经济依赖与第二轮调查中累积生理失调负荷之间的关系。
平均而言,没有证据表明男性的经济依赖与更高的累积生理失调负荷之间存在关联。然而,性别意识形态具有调节作用;对于那些持有更传统性别态度的男性,经济依赖与更高的累积生理失调负荷相关,而对于那些持有最平等主义态度的男性,经济依赖与更低的累积生理失调负荷相关。
研究结果强调了多种男性气概的存在,并表明经济依赖对男性健康的影响是负面还是正面,取决于男性对女性作为主要经济支柱所赋予的意义。