Shi Yulin, Yao Xinghua, Xu Jiatuo, Hu Xiaojuan, Tu Liping, Lan Fang, Cui Ji, Cui Longtao, Huang Jingbin, Li Jun, Bi Zijuan, Li Jiacai
Basic Medical College, Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Pudong, China.
Shanghai Innovation Center of TCM Health Service, Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Pudong, China.
Front Physiol. 2022 Feb 7;12:708742. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2021.708742. eCollection 2021.
Fatigue is a common and subjective symptom, which is associated with many diseases and suboptimal health status. A reliable and evidence-based approach is lacking to distinguish disease fatigue and non-disease fatigue. This study aimed to establish a method for early differential diagnosis of fatigue, which can be used to distinguish disease fatigue from non-disease fatigue, and to investigate the feasibility of characterizing fatigue states in a view of tongue and pulse data analysis.
Tongue and Face Diagnosis Analysis-1 (TFDA-1) instrument and Pulse Diagnosis Analysis-1 (PDA-1) instrument were used to collect tongue and pulse data. Four machine learning models were used to perform classification experiments of disease fatigue vs. non-disease fatigue.
The results showed that all the four classifiers over "Tongue & Pulse" joint data showed better performances than those only over tongue data or only over pulse data. The model accuracy rates based on logistic regression, support vector machine, random forest, and neural network were (85.51 ± 1.87)%, (83.78 ± 4.39)%, (83.27 ± 3.48)% and (85.82 ± 3.01)%, and with Area Under Curve estimates of 0.9160 ± 0.0136, 0.9106 ± 0.0365, 0.8959 ± 0.0254 and 0.9239 ± 0.0174, respectively.
This study proposed and validated an innovative, non-invasive differential diagnosis approach. Results suggest that it is feasible to characterize disease fatigue and non-disease fatigue by using objective tongue data and pulse data.
疲劳是一种常见的主观症状,与多种疾病及健康状况不佳相关。目前缺乏可靠且基于证据的方法来区分疾病性疲劳和非疾病性疲劳。本研究旨在建立一种疲劳早期鉴别诊断方法,用于区分疾病性疲劳和非疾病性疲劳,并从舌象和脉象数据分析的角度探讨表征疲劳状态的可行性。
使用舌面诊断分析-1(TFDA-1)仪器和脉象诊断分析-1(PDA-1)仪器收集舌象和脉象数据。采用四种机器学习模型进行疾病性疲劳与非疾病性疲劳的分类实验。
结果表明,所有四个分类器基于“舌象与脉象”联合数据的表现均优于仅基于舌象数据或仅基于脉象数据的表现。基于逻辑回归、支持向量机、随机森林和神经网络的模型准确率分别为(85.51 ± 1.87)%、(83.78 ± 4.39)%、(83.27 ± 3.48)%和(85.82 ± 3.01)%,曲线下面积估计值分别为0.9160 ± 0.0136、0.9106 ± 0.0365、0.8959 ± 0.0254和0.9239 ± 0.0174。
本研究提出并验证了一种创新的、非侵入性的鉴别诊断方法。结果表明,利用客观的舌象数据和脉象数据表征疾病性疲劳和非疾病性疲劳是可行的。