Mellos Eleftherios, Paparrigopoulos Thomas
Psychiatrist - Psychotherapist, "ATHENA" Programme, OKANA - First Department of Psychiatry, Medical School, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens & Secretary of Section on Substance Abuse, Hellenic Psychiatric Association, Athens, Greece.
Professor of Psychiatry, First Department of Psychiatry, Medical School, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Eginition Hospital & Chairman of Section on Substance Abuse, Hellenic Psychiatric Association, Athens, Greece.
Psychiatriki. 2022 Mar 28;33(1):17-20. doi: 10.22365/jpsych.2022.072. Epub 2022 Feb 21.
The COVID-19 pandemic is associated with increased levels of anxiety, fear, sadness, difficulty adjusting, symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder and suicidality, both in the general population and specific subgroups. The presence of this type of psychopathology increases the risk of involvement with or worsens the use of addictive substances and alcohol as a maladaptive coping strategy.1 According to these data, people with substance use disorders are a population at high risk for COVID-19 infection and serious illness. Α large controlled retrospective case study in the US found that people with substance use disorders are significantly more vulnerable to COVID-19 and its complications (primarily those with opioid use disorder OR = 10.21 and with tobacco use disorder OR = 8.25), and that the course and outcome of the disease (hospitalization, death) was worse than in non-dependent individuals. The main culprits are increased physical co-morbidity (frequent respiratory and cardiovascular problems), poor health and living conditions, marginalization and difficulties in accessing health services. 2,3 Ιnternational epidemiological data during the first months of the pandemic regarding the use of addictive substances do not lead to safe conclusions. A cross-sectional online epidemiological study conducted on a sample of 36,538 adults from 21 European countries between April and July 2020 found an overall decrease in alcohol use, which was mainly attributed to the reduction of heavy episodic consumption, while at the same time an increase in alcohol consumption among people with severe alcohol use was recorded. Τhe use of cannabis and nicotine showed increasing trends, as well as the use of cocaine, but to a lesser extent, while the use of MDMA (ecstasy) showed a decrease.4 In a review of 45 cross-sectional studies conducted between December 2019 and November 2020, alcohol use was on the rise overall, despite geographical variations, as was the use of other addictive substances, cannabis in particular.5 It should be noted that those who increased alcohol use during quarantine were those exhibiting higher levels of negative emotionality mechanisms.6 In Greece, an online cross-sectional survey in April 2020 in the general population during the first lockdown showed a reduction in alcohol use (43.7% of alcohol users reduced or quit), a reduction in cannabis (67.3% quit), while 33.3% increased nicotine use. These changes were attributed to the limitation of alcohol availability, social distancing, changes in daily routine and income reduction.7,8 Also, wastewater samples from Athens, analyzed by the Laboratory of Analytical Chemistry of EKPA, showed a significant increase in the use of cocaine (67%), amphetamine (350%) and methamphetamine (37%), and a decrease in the use of MDMA (- 38%) during the first lockdown, compared to the corresponding period of the previous year.9 Analysis of wastewater samples from other European cities "suggest that levels of use of most drugs appear generally lower during the initial lockdowns, but then appear to bounce back once lockdown was lifted. A comparison with 2019 appears to suggest similar overall consumption of most drugs, and in several cities possibly even higher levels, based on this data source. Exceptions here appear to be MDMA and methamphetamine, two drugs for which the levels observed in 2020 appear lower in most of the participating cities".10,11 There were also changes in the locations of use of the substances, as with the periodic restrictions the use was transferred mainly at home and in open public spaces; in some cases, it was associated with increased intravenous use and cases of intoxication. Finally, intermittent difficulties in drug availability and trafficking have led users to search for other substances, increase experimentation and multidrug use, and make online purchases. In addition, there is concern about the increasing abuse of benzodiazepines, which are either diverted from therapeutic use or appear on the illicit market, often as new benzodiazepines.10,12 According to the European Monitoring Center for Drugs and Drug Addiction (EMCDDA), "the drug market has been remarkably resilient to disruption caused by the pandemic" … Drug trafficking has adapted to the new conditions with changes in routes and methods of trafficking, and by further enhancing the digital presence of the drug market… "Any reductions in drug consumption seen during the initial lockdowns rapidly disappeared as social distancing measures were eased. In general terms, there appears to have been less consumer interest in drugs usually associated with recreational events, such as MDMA, and greater interest in drugs linked with home use. However, the easing of restrictions … during the summer was associated with a rebound in the levels of use". Also, "survey data suggest that those using drugs occasionally prior to COVID-19 may have reduced or even ceased their use during the pandemic, but more-regular users may have increased their drug consumption".10 Measures taken to control the pandemic have reduced and modified the mental health and addiction treatment services provided. Although services have been adequately restored, there has initially been a 60% reduction in the availability and provision of detoxification services in Europe.13 Live contact, mainly at group level, was significantly reduced or stopped altogether for a long period, as well as the frequency of individual appointments. Therapeutic programs sought to respond to the new conditions using technology and telemedicine, providing online group support and psychotherapy. Substitution treatment programs have become more flexible by providing long-term pharmaceutical substitutes (take home) to prevent users from moving. There have also been facilitations in prescribing by treating physicians. Thus, the addicts' contact with the treatment process was maintained, but it was insufficient to meet their increased needs during this period. In conclusion, it should be noted that substance use appears to have an autonomous dynamism in relation to the pandemic and the consequent psychopathology, being in a "loose" causal relationship with it. Therefore, hasty and untimely generalizations should be avoided, and easy conclusions should not be drawn through extrapolations from previous socio-economic crises of different types or through partial spatiotemporal understandings, which are usually presented by the media in the form of negative alarming information.
新冠疫情与普通人群及特定亚组中焦虑、恐惧、悲伤、适应困难、创伤后应激障碍症状和自杀倾向水平的上升有关。这类精神病理学状况的存在会增加使用成瘾物质和酒精作为适应不良应对策略的风险,或使这种情况恶化。根据这些数据,患有物质使用障碍的人群是感染新冠病毒及出现重症的高危人群。美国一项大型对照回顾性病例研究发现,患有物质使用障碍的人群感染新冠病毒及其并发症的风险显著更高(主要是阿片类物质使用障碍者的优势比为10.21,烟草使用障碍者的优势比为8.25),而且疾病的病程和结局(住院、死亡)比未成瘾者更糟。主要原因包括身体共病增加(常见呼吸和心血管问题)、健康状况和生活条件差、边缘化以及获得医疗服务困难。在疫情最初几个月,关于成瘾物质使用的国际流行病学数据无法得出可靠结论。2020年4月至7月期间对来自21个欧洲国家的36538名成年人样本进行的一项横断面在线流行病学研究发现,酒精使用总体有所减少,这主要归因于重度饮酒量的减少,与此同时,重度酒精使用者的酒精消费量有所增加。大麻和尼古丁的使用呈上升趋势,可卡因的使用也呈上升趋势,但幅度较小,而摇头丸的使用呈下降趋势。在对2019年12月至2020年11月期间开展的45项横断面研究的综述中发现,尽管存在地域差异,但酒精使用总体呈上升趋势,其他成瘾物质尤其是大麻的使用也是如此。应当指出,在隔离期间增加酒精使用的是那些表现出较高水平负面情绪机制的人。在希腊,2020年4月在首次封锁期间对普通人群进行的一项在线横断面调查显示,酒精使用减少(43.7%的酒精使用者减少或戒酒),大麻使用减少(67.3%的人戒用),而33.3%的人增加了尼古丁使用。这些变化归因于酒精供应受限、社交距离、日常活动改变和收入减少。此外,雅典大学化学分析实验室分析的雅典废水样本显示,与上一年同期相比,在首次封锁期间,可卡因(67%)、苯丙胺(350%)和甲基苯丙胺(37%)的使用显著增加,摇头丸的使用减少(-38%)。对其他欧洲城市废水样本的分析“表明,在最初的封锁期间,大多数毒品的使用水平总体上似乎较低,但一旦封锁解除,使用水平似乎会反弹。基于该数据源,与2019年相比,大多数毒品的总体消费量似乎相似,在一些城市甚至可能更高。这里的例外似乎是摇头丸和甲基苯丙胺,在大多数参与城市中,2020年观察到的这两种毒品的使用水平似乎较低”。物质使用地点也发生了变化,随着定期限制措施的实施,使用主要转移到了家中和户外公共场所;在某些情况下,这与静脉注射使用增加和中毒病例增多有关。最后,毒品供应和贩运方面的间歇性困难导致使用者寻找其他物质、增加尝试和多药使用,并进行网购。此外,人们还担心苯二氮䓬类药物的滥用日益增加,这些药物要么从治疗用途中转移出来,要么出现在非法市场上,通常是新型苯二氮䓬类药物。根据欧洲毒品和药物成瘾监测中心(EMCDDA)的说法,“毒品市场对疫情造成的干扰具有显著的复原力”……毒品贩运通过改变贩运路线和方法,并进一步加强毒品市场的数字存在,适应了新情况……“在最初的封锁期间看到的任何毒品消费减少,随着社交距离措施的放松迅速消失。一般来说,消费者对通常与娱乐活动相关的毒品(如摇头丸)的兴趣似乎降低,而对与家庭使用相关的毒品的兴趣增加。然而,夏季限制措施的放松……与使用水平的反弹有关”。而且,“调查数据表明,在新冠疫情之前偶尔使用毒品的人在疫情期间可能减少甚至停止了使用,但更经常使用毒品的人可能增加了毒品消费”。为控制疫情采取的措施减少并改变了提供的心理健康和成瘾治疗服务。尽管服务已充分恢复,但欧洲戒毒服务的可及性和提供量最初减少了60%。主要在群体层面的现场接触显著减少或长期完全停止,个人预约的频率也是如此。治疗项目试图利用技术和远程医疗应对新情况,提供在线群体支持和心理治疗。替代治疗项目通过提供长期药物替代品(带回家)变得更加灵活,以防止使用者流动。治疗医生在开处方方面也更加便利。因此,吸毒者与治疗过程的接触得以维持,但在此期间不足以满足他们增加的需求。总之,应当指出,物质使用在与疫情及随之而来的精神病理学方面似乎具有自主动态性,与疫情存在“松散”的因果关系。因此,应避免仓促和不及时的概括,不应通过从以往不同类型的社会经济危机进行推断或通过部分时空理解轻易得出结论,而媒体通常以负面警示信息的形式呈现这些理解。