Department of Civil Engineering, University of Debrecen, Debrecen, Hungary.
Agglomeration and Social Networks Lendület Research Group, Centre for Economic- and Regional Studies, Budapest, Hungary.
PLoS One. 2022 Mar 17;17(3):e0265652. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0265652. eCollection 2022.
The co-editor networks of academic journals are generally examined at the journal level. This paper investigates the geographies of the global co-editor network in oncology through the lens of cities. After using different network methods to analyze the global co-editor network, we found that the network can be characterized by a core-periphery structure. The dense core is occupied by many highly interconnected cities, whereas the periphery contains many cities maintaining loose connections with the core cities. The core shows an asymmetric dual sub-core structure. The greater sub-core is constituted by Northern American cities with New York, Washington DC, Boston, Houston, and Los Angeles in the center, whereas the smaller sub-core is formed by Asian cities and centered on Tokyo, Seoul, Osaka, Beijing, and Shanghai. The European core cities do not form a well-outlined sub-core but produce a ringlike shape around the Northern American core. This structure of the co-editor network is a consequence of the prestige effect still characterizing global science. Many European and Chinese journals tend to employ Northern American editors (US-based editors in the first place) to help increase the reputation of the journal. However, US-based journals are more interested in recruiting American editors from the top-ranked national cancer centers and universities rather than outside of the country.
学术期刊的合作编辑网络通常在期刊层面进行研究。本文通过城市视角考察肿瘤学期刊的全球合作编辑网络的地理学特征。在使用不同的网络方法分析全球合作编辑网络后,我们发现该网络可以用核心-边缘结构来描述。密集的核心由许多高度互联的城市占据,而边缘则包含许多与核心城市保持松散联系的城市。核心呈现出不对称的双亚核心结构。较大的亚核心由北美城市构成,以纽约、华盛顿特区、波士顿、休斯顿和洛杉矶为中心,而较小的亚核心则由亚洲城市组成,以东京、首尔、大阪、北京和上海为中心。欧洲核心城市并没有形成一个轮廓分明的亚核心,而是围绕着北美核心形成了一个环形。这种合作编辑网络的结构是全球科学仍然具有声望效应的结果。许多欧洲和中国期刊倾向于聘请北美的编辑(首先是美国的编辑)来帮助提高期刊的声誉。然而,美国期刊更倾向于从排名最高的国家癌症中心和大学招募美国编辑,而不是在国外。