May Andrew, Kopecki Zlatko, Carney Bernard, Cowin Allison
Burns Surgery, The Women's and Children's Hospital, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia.
Future Industries Institute, University of South Australia, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia.
ANZ J Surg. 2022 May;92(5):1199-1205. doi: 10.1111/ans.17598. Epub 2022 Mar 18.
Antimicrobial silver has had a role in wound antisepsis throughout history and, with the rise in acquired antibiotic resistance, silver dressings are once again commonly used. Issues with silver dressings include the important environmental consideration of nanoparticle manufacture, and the significant financial cost of these products. One solution to these problems may be to adopt an opened-but-unused model of wound care whereby dressing materials are used in piecemeal fashion and excess stored in between dressing changes. Due to a lack of literature on the topic, this project was designed with the aim of testing the antimicrobial efficacy of available silver dressings during storage after opening.
Four commonly used silver dressings were tested for antimicrobial activity using a zone of inhibition assay against clinically important pathogens. The assay was performed on opening of dressings and repeated over 3 months in storage at 4, 25 or 37°C. Analysis was performed using repeated measures ANOVA. Swab cultures were taken at each simulated dressing change to detect microbial contamination of the dressings during storage.
There was no effect of time or storage temperature on the zone of inhibition over the 12 week test period. No swabs taken returned culture consistent with microbial contamination of stored dressings.
Opened silver dressings maintain antimicrobial activity for at least 12 weeks in storage and are resistant to contamination. An opened-but-unused model for wound care is likely to improve cost-effectiveness while preserving effectiveness and safety.
抗菌银在伤口消毒领域有着悠久的历史,随着获得性抗生素耐药性的增加,银敷料再次被广泛使用。银敷料存在的问题包括纳米颗粒制造对环境的重大影响以及这些产品的高昂成本。解决这些问题的一个办法可能是采用一种开放但未使用的伤口护理模式,即敷料材料以零碎的方式使用,多余的敷料在换药期间储存起来。由于缺乏关于该主题的文献,本项目旨在测试开封后储存期间现有银敷料的抗菌效果。
使用抑菌圈试验对四种常用银敷料针对临床重要病原体的抗菌活性进行测试。在敷料开封时进行该试验,并在4℃、25℃或37℃下储存3个月期间重复进行。使用重复测量方差分析进行分析。在每次模拟换药时采集拭子培养物,以检测储存期间敷料的微生物污染情况。
在12周的测试期内,时间或储存温度对抑菌圈没有影响。采集的拭子培养物均未显示与储存敷料的微生物污染一致的结果。
开封后的银敷料在储存至少12周内仍保持抗菌活性且不易被污染。开放但未使用的伤口护理模式可能会提高成本效益,同时保持有效性和安全性。