Monroy-Gómez-Franco Luis, Vélez-Grajales Roberto, López-Calva Luis F
The Graduate Center, City University of New York, USA.
Centro de Estudios Espinosa Yglesias, Mexico.
Int J Educ Dev. 2022 May;91:102581. doi: 10.1016/j.ijedudev.2022.102581. Epub 2022 Mar 15.
In this paper, we use a new database for Mexico to model the possible long-run effects of the pandemic on learning. First, based on the framework of Neidhöffer et al. (2021), we estimate the loss of schooling due to the transition from in-person to remote learning using data from the National Survey on Social Mobility (ESRU-EMOVI-2017), census data, and national statistics of COVID-19 incidence. In this estimation, we account for the attenuation capacity of households by econsidering the parental educational attainment and the economic resources available to the household in the calculation of the short-run cost. Secondly, we estimate the potential long-run consequences of this shock through a calibrated learning profile for five Mexican regions following Kaffenberger and Pritchett (2020a, 2020b). Assuming the distance learning policy adopted by the Mexican government is entirely effective, our results indicate that a learning loss equivalent to the learning during a third of a school year in the short run translates into a learning loss equivalent to an entire school year further up the educational career of students. On the other hand, if the policy was ineffective, the short-run loss increases to an entire school year and becomes a loss of two years of learning in the long run. Our results suggest substantial variation at the regional level, with the most affected region, the South experiencing a loss thrice as large as that of the least affected region, the Centre region.
在本文中,我们使用一个针对墨西哥的新数据库来模拟疫情对学习可能产生的长期影响。首先,基于Neidhöffer等人(2021年)的框架,我们利用社会流动性全国调查(ESRU - EMOVI - 2017)的数据、人口普查数据以及新冠疫情发病率的国家统计数据,估算从面对面学习过渡到远程学习所导致的在校学习损失。在这一估算过程中,我们通过在计算短期成本时考虑父母的教育程度以及家庭可获得的经济资源,来考量家庭的缓冲能力。其次,我们根据Kaffenberger和Pritchett(2020a,2020b)的研究,通过为墨西哥五个地区校准学习概况,来估算这一冲击可能产生的长期后果。假设墨西哥政府采取的远程学习政策完全有效,我们的结果表明,短期内相当于一学年三分之一时间的学习损失,在学生的教育生涯后期会转化为相当于一整个学年的学习损失。另一方面,如果该政策无效,短期损失将增加到一整个学年,并且从长期来看会变成两年的学习损失。我们的结果表明,各地区存在显著差异,受影响最大的地区——南部地区的损失是受影响最小的地区——中部地区损失的三倍。