Wang Yingying, Zhao Xinping, Zang Jinxin, Li Yurong, Dong Xiaolian, Jiang Feng, Wang Na, Jiang Lufang, Jiang Qingwu, Fu Chaowei
NHC Key Laboratory of Health Technology Assessment, School of Public Health, Fudan University, Shanghai 200032, China.
Deqing County Center for Disease Prevention and Control, Huzhou 550004, China.
Antibiotics (Basel). 2022 Mar 17;11(3):407. doi: 10.3390/antibiotics11030407.
Antibiotics are widely used in clinics, livestock farms and the aquaculture industry. A variety of antibiotics in foods and drinking water may lead to important and inadvertent dietary exposure However, the profile of dietary exposure to antibiotics in humans is not well-explored. East China is an economically developed area with a high usage of antibiotics and a high rate of antibiotic resistance (ABR). This study aimed to evaluate the total intake level of antibiotics in humans via foods and drinking water based on a community population in East China.
A total of 600 local residents from 194 households were recruited into this study in Deqing County of Zhejiang Province since June 2019. Each subject was asked to fill a food frequency questionnaire to report their daily consumption of foods and drinking water. Tap water samples were collected from ten households and twenty-one antibiotics of five categories were selected to detect in drinking water. Data of antibiotic residues in animal-derived foods were obtained from the notification of unqualified edible agricultural products after special supervision sampling inspection in Deqing County. The human dietary exposure to antibiotics was estimated by combining the data of antibiotic contamination in foods and drinking water, and the information of dietary consumption.
Of twenty-one antibiotics selected, subjects were exposed to a total of sixteen antibiotics, ranging from 15.12 to 1128 μg/day via two main dietary routes (animal-derived foods and drinking water). The overall dietary exposure level varied greatly in the antibiotics detected and their sources. Compared with other antibiotics, enrofloxacin made the most contributions in terms of dietary exposure, with a median exposure level of 120.19 μg/day (IQR: 8.39-698.78 μg/day), followed by sulfamethazine (median: 32.95 μg/day, IQR: 2.77-162.55 μg/day) and oxytetracycline (median: 28.50 μg/day, IQR: 2.22-146.58 μg/day). The estimated exposure level via drinking water (at the ng/day level, median: 26.74 ng/day, IQR: 16.05-37.44 ng/day) was significantly and substantially lower than those via animal-derived foods (at the μg/day level, median: 216.38 μg/day, IQR: 87.52-323.00 μg/day). The overall dietary exposure level also showed differences in sex and age. Males and youths were more likely to be exposed to antibiotics via dietary routes than others.
The community population investigated in East China was extensively exposed to multiple antibiotics via dietary routes. Long-term exposure to low-dose antibiotics in animal-derived foods was the primary dietary exposure route, compared with drinking water. Enrofloxacin contributed to the major body burden of dietary exposure, based on the combination of consumption of aquatic products and considerable enrofloxacin residues in them. Although the human dietary exposure level to antibiotics via drinking water and animal-derived foods ranged from ng/day to μg/L, their chronic toxicity and the accumulation and spread of ABR may be potential hazards to humans. Therefore, long-term monitoring of antibiotic contaminations in foods and drinking water, and human dietary antibiotic exposure is warranted.
抗生素在诊所、畜牧场和水产养殖业中广泛使用。食品和饮用水中的多种抗生素可能导致重要且意外的膳食暴露。然而,人类膳食中抗生素暴露的情况尚未得到充分研究。中国东部是经济发达地区,抗生素使用量高且抗生素耐药率也高。本研究旨在基于中国东部的社区人群评估通过食物和饮用水摄入抗生素的总量水平。
自2019年6月起,在浙江省德清县招募了来自194户家庭的600名当地居民参与本研究。要求每位受试者填写食物频率问卷,以报告其日常食物和饮用水的摄入量。从十户家庭采集自来水样本,并选择五类共21种抗生素检测饮用水。动物源性食品中抗生素残留数据来自德清县专项监督抽检后不合格食用农产品的通报。通过结合食品和饮用水中抗生素污染数据以及膳食消费信息,估算人类膳食中抗生素的暴露量。
在所选择的21种抗生素中,受试者通过两种主要膳食途径(动物源性食品和饮用水)总共接触到16种抗生素,暴露量范围为15.12至1128μg/天。在检测到的抗生素及其来源方面,总体膳食暴露水平差异很大。与其他抗生素相比,恩诺沙星在膳食暴露方面贡献最大,中位暴露水平为120.19μg/天(四分位间距:8.39 - 698.78μg/天),其次是磺胺二甲嘧啶(中位值:32.95μg/天,四分位间距:2.77 - 162.55μg/天)和土霉素(中位值:28.50μg/天,四分位间距:2.22 - 146.58μg/天)。通过饮用水的估计暴露水平(以ng/天计,中位值:26.74ng/天,四分位间距:16.05 - 37.44ng/天)显著低于通过动物源性食品的暴露水平(以μg/天计,中位值:216.38μg/天,四分位间距:87.52 - 323.00μg/天)。总体膳食暴露水平在性别和年龄上也存在差异。男性和年轻人通过膳食途径接触抗生素的可能性比其他人更高。
中国东部调查的社区人群通过膳食途径广泛接触多种抗生素。与饮用水相比,长期低剂量接触动物源性食品中的抗生素是主要的膳食暴露途径。基于水产品的消费以及其中大量的恩诺沙星残留,恩诺沙星导致了膳食暴露的主要身体负担。尽管人类通过饮用水和动物源性食品摄入抗生素的膳食暴露水平范围为ng/天至μg/L,但它们的慢性毒性以及抗生素耐药性的积累和传播可能对人类构成潜在危害。因此,有必要长期监测食品和饮用水中的抗生素污染以及人类膳食中抗生素的暴露情况。