MRC Biostatistics Unit, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK
Postgraduate School of Public Health, Department of Biomedical Sciences for Health, University of Milan, Milan, Italy.
BMJ Open. 2022 Mar 24;12(3):e054859. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2021-054859.
For people with symptomatic COVID-19, the relative risks of hospital admission, death without hospital admission and recovery without admission, and the times to those events, are not well understood. We describe how these quantities varied with individual characteristics, and through the first wave of the pandemic, in Milan, Italy.
A cohort study of 27 598 people with known COVID-19 symptom onset date in Milan, Italy, testing positive between February and June 2020 and followed up until 17 July 2020. The probabilities of different events, and the times to events, were estimated using a mixture multistate model.
The risk of death without hospital admission was higher in March and April (for non-care home residents, 6%-8% compared with 2%-3% in other months) and substantially higher for care home residents (22%-29% in March). For all groups, the probabilities of hospitalisation decreased from February to June. The probabilities of hospitalisation also increased with age, and were higher for men, substantially lower for healthcare workers and care home residents, and higher for people with comorbidities. Times to hospitalisation and confirmed recovery also decreased throughout the first wave. Combining these results with our previously developed model for events following hospitalisation, the overall symptomatic case fatality risk was 15.8% (15.4%-16.2%).
The highest risks of death before hospital admission coincided with periods of severe burden on the healthcare system in Lombardy. Outcomes for care home residents were particularly poor. Outcomes improved as the first wave waned, community healthcare resources were reinforced and testing became more widely available.
对于有症状的 COVID-19 患者,住院、非住院死亡和无需住院即可康复的相对风险,以及达到这些结果的时间,目前还没有很好的了解。我们描述了这些数量如何随个体特征以及意大利米兰第一波大流行而变化。
这是一项队列研究,纳入了意大利米兰的 27598 名已知 COVID-19 症状发作日期的患者,这些患者在 2020 年 2 月至 6 月间检测出阳性,并随访至 2020 年 7 月 17 日。使用混合多状态模型估计不同事件的概率和发生时间。
非护理院居民在 3 月和 4 月(与其他月份的 2%-3%相比)死亡但无需住院的风险较高(6%-8%),而护理院居民的风险则高得多(3 月为 22%-29%)。对于所有群体,住院的可能性从 2 月到 6 月逐渐降低。住院的可能性也随年龄增加而增加,男性较高,医护人员和护理院居民较低,合并症患者较高。住院和确诊康复的时间也在整个第一波疫情中缩短。将这些结果与我们之前开发的住院后事件模型相结合,总体症状病例死亡率为 15.8%(15.4%-16.2%)。
在伦巴第地区医疗系统负担最重的时候,非住院死亡的风险最高。护理院居民的结果尤其不佳。随着第一波疫情的减弱,社区医疗资源得到加强,检测变得更加广泛,结果有所改善。