Institute of Population Health, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK.
UCD Centre for Disability Studies, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Eur J Neurol. 2022 Jul;29(7):1873-1884. doi: 10.1111/ene.15336. Epub 2022 May 7.
This position paper makes recommendations following an audit of care provided to people presenting with a seizure to emergency departments (EDs) in Europe.
Participating countries were asked to include five hospitals agreeing to identify 50 consecutive seizure patients presenting to their ED between 1 August 2016 and 31 August 2017. Anonymous data were collected to a web database. Where quoted, percentages are mean site values and ranges are the 10th-90th centile.
Data were collected on 2204 ED visits (47 sites, up to six per country, across 15 countries): 1270 (58%) known epilepsy, 299 (14%) previous blackouts but no epilepsy diagnosis, 634 (29%) with a first seizure. Wide variability was identified for most variables. Of those with known epilepsy, 41.2% (range 26.2%-59.6%) attended the ED in the previous 12 months, but only 64.7% (range 37.2%-79.8%) had seen an epilepsy specialist in the previous 12 months. 67.7% (range 34.0%-100%) were admitted, 53.1% to a neurology ward (range 0.0%-88.9%). Only 37.5% first seizure patients (range 0.0%-71.4%) were given advice about driving.
It is recommended that in Europe guidance is agreed on the management and onward referral of those presenting to the ED with a seizure; a referral process is created that can be easily implemented; it is ensured that the seizure services receive referrals and see the patients within a short time period; and a simple system is developed and implemented to allow continuous monitoring of key indices of epilepsy care.
本文基于对欧洲急诊科(ED)接诊癫痫患者的护理情况进行审计后提出相关建议。
要求参与国家选取 5 家医院,每家医院连续纳入 50 例 2016 年 8 月 1 日至 2017 年 8 月 31 日就诊 ED 的癫痫患者。匿名数据被录入网络数据库。若引用百分比,则为各监测点平均值,范围为第 10 百分位数至第 90 百分位数。
共收集了 2204 例 ED 就诊(来自 15 个国家的 47 个监测点,每个国家 6 个监测点以下)数据:1270 例(58%)已知癫痫,299 例(14%)既往晕厥但无癫痫诊断,634 例(29%)为首次发作。多数变量存在较大差异。已知癫痫患者中,41.2%(26.2%-59.6%)在过去 12 个月内就诊过 ED,但仅 64.7%(37.2%-79.8%)在过去 12 个月内看过癫痫专家。67.7%(34.0%-100%)被收治入院,53.1%(0.0%-88.9%)收入神经内科病房。仅有 37.5%(0.0%-71.4%)首次发作患者获得驾驶相关建议。
建议在欧洲范围内达成关于 ED 接诊癫痫患者的管理和转介指南;建立并推广转介流程,确保癫痫服务机构在短时间内接收和诊治患者;开发并实施简单系统,对癫痫治疗的关键指标进行持续监测。