Vita Antonio, Barlati Stefano, Bellomo Antonello, Poli Paolo Fusar, Masi Gabriele, Nobili Lino, Serafini Gianluca, Zuddas Alessandro, Vicari Stefano
Department of Clinical and Experimental Sciences, University of Brescia, Brescia, Italy.
Department of Clinical and Experimental Medicine, University of Foggia, Foggia, Italy.
Front Psychiatry. 2022 Mar 30;13:844098. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2022.844098. eCollection 2022.
BACKGROUND: The current conceptualization of schizophrenia as neurodevelopmental disorder should lead to innovative public health policies in terms of a reorganization of the mental health care systems, particularly in the transition from adolescence to adulthood, to reduce personal, familiar, and social costs and burdens. The purpose of the project was to perform a survey among a panel of Italian schizophrenia experts, to share evidence-based information on adolescent schizophrenia and explore the degree of consensus among professionals in the following four macro-areas: early diagnosis; pharmacological treatment; health care system organization and transition process from adolescent to adulthood; and psychosocial interventions. METHODS: The consensus process consisted of a two-step web-based Delphi method, which took place between June and November 2021. The survey was developed by a panel of four psychiatrists and four child neuropsychiatrists, identified as key opinion leaders (KOLs). The KOLs identified 21 statements involving a total of 70 items with a major need of clarification on early-onset schizophrenia (EOS). The survey was distributed to 86 specialists in psychiatry and child neuropsychiatry. RESULTS: The results revealed a large agreement among the expert group on all the investigated areas of adolescent schizophrenia patterns of care and management. Consensus was ultimately reached for 67 items of the Delphi survey (95.7%), while negative consensus was reached for 2 items and no consensus was reached for 1 item. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, results showed a significant gap between the acquired scientific knowledge and clinical practice. In this scenario, it should be necessary to plan specific initiatives at a multiple level, to edit recommendations on clinical decision-making, as well as to prompt changes at the political and organizational levels, also involving scientific societies, patients, and family associations, to overcome the barriers that delay the implementation process.
背景:目前将精神分裂症概念化为神经发育障碍,这应促使在精神卫生保健系统重组方面制定创新的公共卫生政策,特别是在从青少年到成年的过渡阶段,以降低个人、家庭和社会成本及负担。该项目的目的是在一组意大利精神分裂症专家中进行一项调查,分享关于青少年精神分裂症的循证信息,并探讨专业人员在以下四个主要领域的共识程度:早期诊断;药物治疗;卫生保健系统组织以及从青少年到成年的过渡过程;心理社会干预。 方法:共识达成过程包括基于网络的两步德尔菲法,于2021年6月至11月进行。该调查由一个由四名精神科医生和四名儿童神经精神科医生组成的小组制定,这些医生被确定为关键意见领袖(KOL)。关键意见领袖确定了21条陈述,总共涉及70个项目,这些项目对早发性精神分裂症(EOS)有很大的澄清需求。该调查分发给了86名精神科和儿童神经精神科专家。 结果:结果显示,专家组在青少年精神分裂症护理和管理模式的所有调查领域都达成了很大程度的一致。最终,德尔菲调查的67个项目(95.7%)达成了共识,2个项目达成了负面共识,1个项目未达成共识。 结论:总体而言,结果表明已获得的科学知识与临床实践之间存在显著差距。在这种情况下,有必要在多个层面规划具体举措,编辑临床决策建议,并促使政治和组织层面进行变革,同时也让科学协会、患者和家庭协会参与进来,以克服阻碍实施过程的障碍。
Front Psychiatry. 2022-3-30
Eur Psychiatry. 2020-3-13
BMC Health Serv Res. 2022-1-2
Joint Bone Spine. 2017-9-28
Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2025-7-23
Front Psychiatry. 2023-4-14
Eur Psychiatry. 2021-9-21
Schizophr Bull. 2021-4-29