Cullen Mark R, Lemeshow Adina R, Russo Leo J, Barnes David M, Ababio Yaa, Habtezion Aida
Independent Researcher, 27766 Stirrup Way, Los Altos Hills, CA 94022, USA.
Global Medical Epidemiology, Worldwide Medical and Safety, Pfizer Inc., 235 E 42nd St., New York, NY 10017, USA.
Healthcare (Basel). 2022 Mar 23;10(4):603. doi: 10.3390/healthcare10040603.
Wide disparities in health status exist in the United States across race and ethnicity, broadly driven by social determinants of health-most notably race and ethnic group differences in income, education, and occupational status. However, disparities in disease frequency or severity remain underappreciated for many individual diseases whose distribution in the population varies. Such information is not readily accessible, nor emphasized in treatment guidelines or reviews used by practitioners. Specifically, a summary on disease-specific evidence of disparities from population-based studies is lacking. Our goal was to summarize the published evidence for specific disease disparities in the United States so that this knowledge becomes more widely available "at the bedside". We hope this summary stimulates health equity research at the disease level so that these disparities can be addressed effectively.
A targeted literature review of disorders in Pfizer's current pipeline was conducted. The 38 diseases included metabolic disorders, cancers, inflammatory conditions, dermatologic disorders, rare diseases, and infectious targets of vaccines under development. Online searches in Ovid and Google were performed to identify sources focused on differences in disease rates and severity between non-Hispanic Whites and Black/African Americans, and between non-Hispanic Whites and Hispanics. As a model for how this might be accomplished for all disorders, disparities in disease rates and disease severity were scored to make the results of our review most readily accessible. After primary review of each condition by one author, another undertook an independent review. Differences between reviewers were resolved through discussion.
For Black/African Americans, 29 of the 38 disorders revealed a robust excess in incidence, prevalence, or severity. After sickle cell anemia, the largest excesses in frequency were identified for multiple myeloma and hidradenitis suppurativa. For Hispanics, there was evidence of disparity in 19 diseases. Most notable were metabolic disorders, including non-alcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH).
This review summarized recent disease-specific evidence of disparities based on race and ethnicity across multiple diseases, to inform clinicians and health equity research. Our findings may be well known to researchers and specialists in their respective fields but may not be common knowledge to health care providers or public health and policy institutions. Our hope is that this effort spurs research into the causes of the many disease disparities that exist in the United States.
在美国,健康状况存在广泛的种族和族裔差异,这主要是由健康的社会决定因素驱动的,最显著的是种族和族裔群体在收入、教育和职业地位方面的差异。然而,对于许多在人群中分布各异的个别疾病,其疾病发生率或严重程度的差异仍未得到充分认识。此类信息不易获取,在从业者使用的治疗指南或综述中也未得到强调。具体而言,缺乏基于人群研究的特定疾病差异证据的总结。我们的目标是总结美国特定疾病差异的已发表证据,以便让这些知识在“床边”更广泛地传播。我们希望这一总结能激发疾病层面的健康公平研究,从而有效解决这些差异问题。
对辉瑞公司当前研发管线中的疾病进行了有针对性的文献综述。这38种疾病包括代谢紊乱、癌症、炎症性疾病、皮肤病、罕见病以及正在研发的疫苗的感染性靶点。在Ovid和谷歌上进行了在线搜索,以确定关注非西班牙裔白人与黑人/非裔美国人之间以及非西班牙裔白人与西班牙裔之间疾病发生率和严重程度差异的资料来源。作为针对所有疾病如何实现这一目标的模型,对疾病发生率和疾病严重程度的差异进行了评分,以使我们的综述结果更易于获取。在一位作者对每种疾病进行初步综述后,另一位作者进行了独立综述。评审者之间的差异通过讨论解决。
对于黑人/非裔美国人,38种疾病中有29种在发病率、患病率或严重程度上存在明显过高的情况。除镰状细胞贫血外,多发性骨髓瘤和化脓性汗腺炎的发病率过高最为明显。对于西班牙裔,有19种疾病存在差异证据。最显著的是代谢紊乱,包括非酒精性脂肪性肝炎(NASH)。
本综述总结了近期基于种族和族裔的多种疾病特定差异证据,为临床医生和健康公平研究提供参考。我们的研究结果在各自领域的研究人员和专家中可能是众所周知的,但对于医疗保健提供者或公共卫生及政策机构来说可能并非常识。我们希望这项工作能推动对美国存在的众多疾病差异原因的研究。