Karbeah J'Mag, Murray Camille R, Nakamura Corelle, Brahmbhatt Haley, Cattaneo Elena, Frye Hailey, Shen Erin, Kavalieratos Dio, Johnson Khaliah A
Division of Health Policy and Management (J.K., C.N.), University of Minnesota School of Public Health, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN.
Division of Health Policy and Management (C.R.M.), University of North Carolina Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC.
J Pain Symptom Manage. 2025 Jan;69(1):44-52. doi: 10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2024.09.021. Epub 2024 Oct 1.
Racial disparities in health outcomes have historically impacted Black and Native American children with serious illness, yet little is known about how racism shapes the healthcare experiences of these families. To improve care experiences for this population, we must understand the myriad of ways that racism may impact their experiences with serious illness.
We conducted a scoping review and qualitative meta-synthesis of peer-reviewed articles from 1980 to 2022 that included Black and/or Native American parents' or caregivers' experiences of serious illness care. We abstracted study characteristics, and forms of racism mentioned.
Searches yielded 2762 articles, of which six were reviewed based on inclusion criteria. Three key themes emerged from the literature on the experiences of Black families navigating pediatric serious illness that highlight how parents navigate their future after a serious illness diagnosis; how relationships and support networks change after diagnosis; and the challenges associated with navigating grief and suffering after a diagnosis. Institutionalized racism and interpersonal racism were the most identified forms of racism experienced by Black families. None of the articles identified included Native American families.
Our findings highlight the pressing need for further qualitative research to explore the lived experiences of racially minoritized families-especially studies focusing on the experiences of Native American families.
健康结果方面的种族差异历来影响着患有严重疾病的黑人和美国原住民儿童,但对于种族主义如何塑造这些家庭的医疗保健经历却知之甚少。为了改善这一人群的护理体验,我们必须了解种族主义可能影响他们严重疾病经历的多种方式。
1)评估现有严重疾病和姑息治疗文献中对黑人和美国原住民家庭经历的涵盖程度,以及2)探讨种族主义经历如何独特地影响这一人群。
我们对1980年至2022年同行评审文章进行了范围综述和定性元分析,这些文章包括黑人和/或美国原住民父母或照顾者的严重疾病护理经历。我们提取了研究特征以及提到的种族主义形式。
检索得到2762篇文章,其中6篇根据纳入标准进行了审查。关于黑人家庭应对儿科严重疾病经历的文献中出现了三个关键主题,突出了父母在严重疾病诊断后如何规划未来;诊断后人际关系和支持网络如何变化;以及诊断后应对悲伤和痛苦所面临的挑战。制度化种族主义和人际种族主义是黑人家庭经历的最常见种族主义形式。所纳入的文章均未涉及美国原住民家庭。
我们的研究结果凸显了进一步开展定性研究以探索种族少数群体家庭生活经历的迫切需求,尤其是关注美国原住民家庭经历的研究。