Department of Laboratory Medicine, Clinique Saint-Pierre, 1340 Ottignies, Belgium.
COVID-19 Federal Testing Platform and NGS Surveillance Consortium, CHU UCL Namur, 5530 Yvoir, Belgium.
Viruses. 2022 Mar 22;14(4):654. doi: 10.3390/v14040654.
Rapid antigen detection (RAD) tests are commonly used for the diagnosis of SARS-CoV-2 infections. However, with the continuous emergence of new variants of concern (VOC), presenting various mutations potentially affecting the nucleocapsid protein, the analytical performances of these assays should be frequently reevaluated. One hundred and twenty samples were selected and tested with both RT-qPCR and six commercial RAD tests that are commonly sold in Belgian pharmacies. Of these, direct whole-genome sequencing identified the strains present in 116 samples, of which 70 were Delta and 46 were Omicron (BA.1 and BA.1.1 sub-lineages, respectively). The sensitivity across a wide range of Ct values (13.5 to 35.7; median = 21.3) ranged from 70.0% to 92.9% for Delta strains and from 69.6% to 78.3% for Omicron strains. When taking swabs with a low viral load (Ct > 25, corresponding to <4.9 log10 copies/mL), only the Roche RAD test showed acceptable performances for the Delta strains (80.0%), while poor performances were observed for the other RAD tests (20.0% to 40.0%). All the tested devices had poor performances for the Omicron samples with a low viral load (0.0% to 23.1%). The poor performances observed with low viral loads, particularly for the Omicron strain, is an important limitation of RAD tests, which is not sufficiently highlighted in the instructions for use of these devices.
快速抗原检测(RAD)试验常用于 SARS-CoV-2 感染的诊断。然而,随着新的关切变异株(VOC)的不断出现,这些变异株可能在核衣壳蛋白上呈现出各种突变,因此这些检测方法的分析性能应经常重新评估。我们选择了 120 个样本,用 RT-qPCR 和六种在比利时药店常见的商业 RAD 检测方法进行了检测。其中,直接全基因组测序确定了 116 个样本中存在的毒株,其中 70 个是 Delta 株,46 个是奥密克戎株(分别为 BA.1 和 BA.1.1 亚谱系)。在广泛的 Ct 值范围内(13.5 至 35.7;中位数=21.3),Delta 株的敏感性为 70.0%至 92.9%,奥密克戎株的敏感性为 69.6%至 78.3%。对于 Ct 值较高(>25,对应于<4.9 log10 拷贝/mL)、病毒载量较低的拭子,罗氏 RAD 检测方法对 Delta 株显示出可接受的性能(80.0%),而其他 RAD 检测方法的性能较差(20.0%至 40.0%)。对于低病毒载量的奥密克戎样本,所有测试设备的性能均较差(0.0%至 23.1%)。低病毒载量下观察到的性能较差,特别是对于奥密克戎株,这是 RAD 检测方法的一个重要限制,在这些设备的使用说明中没有充分强调。