Department of Emergency and Organ Transplants, University of Bari, Bari, Italy.
Department of Electrical and Information Engineering, Polytechnic of Bari, Bari, Italy.
J Nephrol. 2022 Nov;35(8):1953-1971. doi: 10.1007/s40620-022-01302-3. Epub 2022 May 11.
Aim of nephrologists is to delay the outcome and reduce the number of patients undergoing renal failure (RF) by applying prevention protocols and accurately monitoring chronic kidney disease (CKD) patients. General practitioners and nephrologists are involved in the first and in the late stages of the disease, respectively. Early diagnosis of CKD is an important step in preventing the progression of kidney damage. Our aim was to review publications on machine learning algorithms (MLAs) that can predict early CKD and its progression.
We conducted a systematic review and selected 55 articles on the application of MLAs in CKD. PubMed, Medline, Scopus, Web of Science and IEEE Xplore Digital Library of the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers were searched. The search terms were chronic kidney disease, artificial intelligence, data mining and machine learning algorithms.
MLAs use enormous numbers of predictors combining them in non-linear and highly interactive ways. This ability increases when new data is added. We observed some limitations in the publications: (i) databases were not accurately reviewed by physicians; (ii) databases did not report the ethnicity of the patients; (iii) some databases collected variables that were not important for the diagnosis and progression of CKD; (iv) no information was presented on the native kidney disease causing CKD; (v) no validation of the results in external independent cohorts was provided; and (vi) no insights were given on the MLAs that were used. Overall, there was limited collaboration among experts in electronics, computer science and physicians.
The application of MLAs in kidney diseases may enhance the ability of clinicians to predict CKD and RF, thus improving diagnostic assistance and providing suitable therapeutic decisions. However, it is necessary to improve the development process of MLA tools.
肾病学家的目标是通过应用预防方案和准确监测慢性肾脏病 (CKD) 患者来延迟结局并减少需要进行肾衰竭 (RF) 的患者数量。全科医生和肾病学家分别参与疾病的早期和晚期阶段。CKD 的早期诊断是防止肾脏损伤进展的重要步骤。我们的目的是回顾可预测早期 CKD 及其进展的机器学习算法 (MLA) 的出版物。
我们进行了系统评价,并选择了 55 篇关于 MLA 在 CKD 中的应用的文章。检索了 PubMed、Medline、Scopus、Web of Science 和电气和电子工程师协会的 IEEE Xplore 数字图书馆。搜索词为慢性肾脏病、人工智能、数据挖掘和机器学习算法。
MLA 使用大量的预测因子,以非线性和高度交互的方式将它们组合在一起。当添加新数据时,这种能力会增加。我们在出版物中观察到一些局限性:(i) 医生没有准确地审查数据库;(ii) 数据库没有报告患者的种族;(iii) 一些数据库收集了对 CKD 诊断和进展不重要的变量;(iv) 没有提供导致 CKD 的原生肾脏疾病的信息;(v) 没有提供在外部独立队列中验证结果的信息;(vi) 没有提供关于使用的 MLA 的见解。总体而言,电子、计算机科学和医生之间的专家合作有限。
MLA 在肾脏疾病中的应用可以增强临床医生预测 CKD 和 RF 的能力,从而改善诊断辅助并提供合适的治疗决策。然而,有必要改进 MLA 工具的开发过程。