Center for Children and Families, Department of Psychology, Florida International University.
Amsterdam Public Health Research Institute, Department of Epidemiology and Data Science, Amsterdam University Medical Center.
Psychol Methods. 2023 Apr;28(2):488-506. doi: 10.1037/met0000497. Epub 2022 May 12.
Single case experimental designs (SCEDs) are used to test treatment effects in a wide range of fields and consist of repeated measurements for a single case throughout one or more baseline phases and throughout one or more treatment phases. Recently, mediation analysis has been applied to SCEDs. Mediation analysis decomposes the total treatment-outcome effect into a direct and indirect effect, and therefore aims to unravel the causal processes underlying treatment-outcome effects. The most recent methodological advancement for mediation analysis is the development of causal mediation analysis methodology which clarifies the necessary causal assumptions for mediation analysis. The goal of this article is to derive the causal mediation effects and corresponding standard errors based on piecewise linear regression models for the mediator and outcome and to evaluate the performance of these regression estimators and standard errors. Whereas previous studies estimated the direct and indirect effects as either the change in level or change in trend, we showed that the causal direct and indirect effects incorporate both the change in level and change in trend. Based on our simulation study we showed that for the causal indirect effects, Monte Carlo confidence intervals provided accurate (i.e., = .05) Type I error rates and higher statistical power than normal theory confidence intervals. For the causal direct effects and total effect, normal theory confidence intervals provided accurate Type I error rates and higher statistical power than the Monte Carlo confidence intervals. Limitations and future directions are discussed. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).
单病例实验设计(SCEDs)用于测试广泛领域中的治疗效果,由一个或多个基线阶段和一个或多个治疗阶段中对单个病例的重复测量组成。最近,中介分析已应用于 SCEDs。中介分析将总治疗效果分解为直接和间接效果,因此旨在揭示治疗效果背后的因果过程。中介分析的最新方法学进展是因果中介分析方法的发展,该方法澄清了中介分析的必要因果假设。本文的目的是基于中介和结果的分段线性回归模型推导出因果中介效应及其相应的标准误差,并评估这些回归估计量和标准误差的性能。虽然以前的研究将直接和间接效应估计为水平变化或趋势变化,但我们表明,因果直接和间接效应包含了水平变化和趋势变化。基于我们的模拟研究,我们表明对于因果间接效应,蒙特卡罗置信区间提供了准确的(即 =.05)I 型错误率和比正态理论置信区间更高的统计功效。对于因果直接效应和总效应,正态理论置信区间提供了比蒙特卡罗置信区间更准确的 I 型错误率和更高的统计功效。讨论了局限性和未来方向。(PsycInfo 数据库记录(c)2023 APA,保留所有权利)。