Chen Rong, Mo Xiao, Chen Zhenpeng, Feng Pujie, Li Haiyun
Beijing Key Laboratory of Fundamental Research on Biomechanics in Clinical Application, School of Biomedical Engineering, Capital Medical University, Beijing, China.
Front Neurol. 2022 May 12;13:868395. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2022.868395. eCollection 2022.
The rupture risk assessment of intracranial aneurysms (IAs) is clinically relevant. How to accurately assess the rupture risk of IAs remains a challenge in clinical decision-making.
We aim to build an integrated model to improve the assessment of the rupture risk of IAs.
A total of 148 (39 ruptured and 109 unruptured) IA subjects were retrospectively computed with computational fluid dynamics (CFDs), and the integrated models were proposed by combining machine learning (ML) and deep learning (DL) algorithms. ML algorithms that include random forest (RF), k-nearest neighbor (KNN), XGBoost (XGB), support vector machine (SVM), and LightGBM were, respectively, adopted to classify ruptured and unruptured IAs. A Pointnet DL algorithm was applied to extract hemodynamic cloud features from the hemodynamic clouds obtained from CFD. Morphological variables and hemodynamic parameters along with the extracted hemodynamic cloud features were acted as the inputs to the classification models. The classification results with and without hemodynamic cloud features are computed and compared.
Without consideration of hemodynamic cloud features, the classification accuracy of RF, KNN, XGB, SVM, and LightGBM was 0.824, 0.759, 0.839, 0.860, and 0.829, respectively, and the AUCs of them were 0.897, 0.584, 0.892, 0.925, and 0.890, respectively. With the consideration of hemodynamic cloud features, the accuracy successively increased to 0.908, 0.873, 0.900, 0.926, and 0.917. Meanwhile, the AUCs reached 0.952, 0.881, 0.950, 0.969, and 0.965 eventually. Adding consideration of hemodynamic cloud features, the SVM could perform best with the highest accuracy of 0.926 and AUC of 0.969, respectively.
The integrated model combining ML and DL algorithms could improve the classification of IAs. Adding consideration of hemodynamic cloud features could bring more accurate classification, and hemodynamic cloud features were important for the discrimination of ruptured IAs.
颅内动脉瘤(IA)破裂风险评估具有临床相关性。如何准确评估IA的破裂风险仍是临床决策中的一项挑战。
我们旨在构建一个综合模型以改进对IA破裂风险的评估。
回顾性地对148例IA患者(39例破裂,109例未破裂)进行计算流体动力学(CFD)计算,并结合机器学习(ML)和深度学习(DL)算法提出综合模型。分别采用包括随机森林(RF)、k近邻(KNN)、XGBoost(XGB)、支持向量机(SVM)和LightGBM在内的ML算法对破裂和未破裂的IA进行分类。应用Pointnet DL算法从CFD获得的血流动力学云图中提取血流动力学云特征。形态学变量、血流动力学参数以及提取的血流动力学云特征作为分类模型的输入。计算并比较有无血流动力学云特征时的分类结果。
不考虑血流动力学云特征时,RF、KNN、XGB、SVM和LightGBM的分类准确率分别为0.824、0.759、0.839、0.860和0.829,其曲线下面积(AUC)分别为0.897、0.584、0.892、0.925和0.890。考虑血流动力学云特征时,准确率依次提高到0.908、0.873、0.900、0.926和0.917。同时,AUC最终分别达到0.952、0.881、0.950、0.969和0.965。加入血流动力学云特征的考虑后,SVM表现最佳,准确率最高达到0.926,AUC为0.969。
结合ML和DL算法的综合模型可改善IA的分类。加入血流动力学云特征的考虑可带来更准确的分类,且血流动力学云特征对破裂IA的鉴别很重要。