From the Department of Diagnostic Radiology (Z.S., C.S.Z., B.H., G.M.L., L.J.Z.), Jinling Hospital, Medical School of Nanjing University, Nanjing, Jiangsu, China.
Department of Medical Imaging (G.Z.C.), Nanjing First Hospital, Nanjing, Jiangsu, China.
AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2021 Apr;42(4):648-654. doi: 10.3174/ajnr.A7034. Epub 2021 Mar 4.
Small intracranial aneurysms are being increasingly detected while the rupture risk is not well-understood. We aimed to develop rupture-risk models of small aneurysms by combining clinical, morphologic, and hemodynamic information based on machine learning techniques and to test the models in external validation datasets.
From January 2010 to December 2016, five hundred four consecutive patients with only small aneurysms (<5 mm) detected by CTA and invasive cerebral angiography (or surgery) were retrospectively enrolled and randomly split into training (81%) and internal validation (19%) sets to derive and validate the proposed machine learning models (support vector machine, random forest, logistic regression, and multilayer perceptron). Hemodynamic parameters were obtained using computational fluid dynamics simulation. External validation was performed in other hospitals to test the models.
The support vector machine performed the best with areas under the curve of 0.88 (95% CI, 0.85-0.92) and 0.91 (95% CI, 0.74-0.98) in the training and internal validation datasets, respectively. Feature ranks suggested hemodynamic parameters, including stable flow pattern, concentrated inflow streams, and a small (<50%) flow-impingement zone, and the oscillatory shear index coefficient of variation, were the best predictors of aneurysm rupture. The support vector machine showed an area under the curve of 0.82 (95% CI, 0.69-0.94) in the external validation dataset, and no significant difference was found for the areas under the curve between internal and external validation datasets (= .21).
This study revealed that machine learning had a good performance in predicting the rupture status of small aneurysms in both internal and external datasets. Aneurysm hemodynamic parameters were regarded as the most important predictors.
随着小颅内动脉瘤(<5mm)检出率的增加,其破裂风险仍未得到充分认识。本研究旨在结合临床、形态和血流动力学信息,应用机器学习技术建立小动脉瘤破裂风险模型,并在外部验证数据集上进行验证。
回顾性纳入 2010 年 1 月至 2016 年 12 月期间,由 CTA 和有创脑血管造影(或手术)检出的 504 例单纯小动脉瘤(<5mm)患者,按 81%:19%的比例随机分为训练集和内部验证集,分别建立支持向量机、随机森林、逻辑回归和多层感知机机器学习模型,并进行模型验证。采用计算流体动力学模拟获得血流动力学参数。在其他医院进行外部验证,以评估模型性能。
支持向量机在训练集和内部验证集的曲线下面积分别为 0.88(95%可信区间:0.850.92)和 0.91(95%可信区间:0.740.98),表现最佳。特征排序显示,血流动力学参数,包括稳定的流型、集中的入流流束和较小(<50%)的血流冲击区,以及振荡剪切指数变异系数,是动脉瘤破裂的最佳预测指标。支持向量机在外部验证集的曲线下面积为 0.82(95%可信区间:0.69~0.94),内部和外部验证集的曲线下面积无显著差异(=0.21)。
本研究表明,机器学习在内部和外部数据集预测小动脉瘤破裂方面具有良好的性能。动脉瘤血流动力学参数是最重要的预测指标。