Utrecht University, the Netherlands.
Leiden University, the Netherlands.
Child Maltreat. 2024 May;29(2):388-404. doi: 10.1177/10775595221103420. Epub 2022 Jun 2.
While there is evidence that child maltreatment is positively associated with loneliness, the strength of this association is not yet clear. It is also unclear whether the magnitude and statistical significance of this association varies across groups of individuals. Therefore, this meta-analysis examines whether there are differences in loneliness between individuals with and without maltreatment histories, and which factors may influence the association between child maltreatment and loneliness. A three-level meta-analysis was conducted on 52 studies reporting 116 effect sizes ( = 1,705,493; = 30.93; 49.6% females). Results showed a medium overall effect ( = 0.45, < .001, 95% CI [0.36, 0.53]), indicating that individuals with maltreatment histories, on average, feel lonelier than individuals without maltreatment histories. Moderator analyses showed that effect sizes were larger for emotional abuse and emotional neglect as compared to other types of child maltreatment and decreased when participants were older at the time of loneliness assessment. These findings suggest that individuals with maltreatment histories, especially those who have been emotionally abused and/or emotionally neglected, are vulnerable to experiencing loneliness across the lifespan. The results also suggest that feelings of loneliness warrant attention in prevention and intervention programs for individuals with maltreatment histories.
虽然有证据表明儿童虐待与孤独感呈正相关,但这种关联的强度尚不清楚。也不清楚这种关联的大小和统计学意义是否因个体群体而异。因此,这项荟萃分析旨在探讨是否存在虐待史个体与无虐待史个体之间的孤独感差异,以及哪些因素可能影响儿童虐待与孤独感之间的关联。对 52 项研究报告的 116 个效应量进行了三级荟萃分析(n = 1,705,493; = 30.93;49.6%为女性)。结果表明,总体上存在中等效应( = 0.45, <.001,95%CI [0.36, 0.53]),这表明有虐待史的个体平均比没有虐待史的个体更感到孤独。调节分析表明,与其他类型的儿童虐待相比,情感虐待和情感忽视的效应量更大,而当孤独感评估时参与者年龄更大时,效应量则会减小。这些发现表明,有虐待史的个体,尤其是那些遭受过情感虐待和/或情感忽视的个体,在整个生命周期中都容易感到孤独。研究结果还表明,在有虐待史个体的预防和干预计划中,孤独感值得关注。