Center for Health Economics (CHE), University of York, York, United Kingdom.
MMGH Consulting, Zurich, Switzerland.
PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2022 Jun 13;16(6):e0010471. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0010471. eCollection 2022 Jun.
A pressing need exists to develop vaccines for neglected diseases, including leishmaniasis. However, the development of new vaccines is dependent on their value to two key players-vaccine developers and manufacturers who need to have confidence in the global demand in order to commit to research and production; and governments (or other international funders) who need to signal demand based on the potential public health benefits of the vaccine in their local context, as well as its affordability. A detailed global epidemiological analysis is rarely available before a vaccine enters a market due to lack of resources as well as insufficient global data necessary for such an analysis. Our study seeks to bridge this information gap by providing a generalisable approach to estimating the commercial and public health value of a vaccine in development relying primarily on publicly available Global Burden of Disease (GBD) data. This simplified approach is easily replicable and can be used to guide discussions and investments into vaccines and other health technologies where evidence constraints exist. The approach is demonstrated through the estimation of the demand curve for a future leishmaniasis vaccine.
METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: We project the ability to pay over the period 2030-2040 for a vaccine preventing cutaneous and visceral leishmaniasis (CL / VL), using an illustrative set of countries which account for most of the global disease burden. First, based on previous work on vaccine demand projections in these countries and CL / VL GBD-reported incidence rates, we project the potential long-term impact of the vaccine on disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) averted as a result of reduced incidence. Then, we apply an economic framework to our estimates to determine vaccine affordability based on the abilities to pay of governments and global funders, leading to estimates of the demand and market size. Based on our estimates, the maximum ability-to-pay of a leishmaniasis vaccine (per course, including delivery costs), given the current estimates of incidence and population at risk, is higher than $5 for 25-30% of the countries considered, with the average value-based maximum price, weighted by quantity demanded, being $5.7-6 [$0.3 - $34.5], and total demand of over 560 million courses.
CONCLUSION/SIGNIFICANCE: Our results demonstrate that both the quantity of vaccines estimated to be required by the countries considered as well as their ability-to-pay could make a vaccine for leishmaniasis commercially attractive to potential manufacturers. The methodology used can be equally applied to other technology developments targeting health in developing countries.
迫切需要开发针对被忽视疾病(包括利什曼病)的疫苗。然而,新疫苗的开发取决于两个关键参与者的价值:疫苗开发商和制造商需要对全球需求有信心,才能承诺进行研究和生产;政府(或其他国际资助者)需要根据疫苗在当地的潜在公共卫生效益及其可负担性,发出对疫苗的需求信号。由于资源匮乏以及进行此类分析所需的全球数据不足,在疫苗进入市场之前,很少有详细的全球流行病学分析。我们的研究旨在通过主要依靠公开的全球疾病负担(GBD)数据,提供一种可推广的方法来估算正在开发中的疫苗的商业和公共卫生价值,从而弥补这一信息差距。这种简化方法易于复制,可用于指导有证据限制的疫苗和其他卫生技术的讨论和投资。通过估算未来利什曼病疫苗的需求曲线来展示该方法。
方法/主要发现:我们使用占全球疾病负担大部分的一组有代表性的国家,预测 2030 年至 2040 年期间对预防皮肤利什曼病和内脏利什曼病(CL/VL)的疫苗的支付能力。首先,根据这些国家以前在疫苗需求预测方面的工作以及 CL/VL GBD 报告的发病率数据,我们预测疫苗对因发病率降低而避免的残疾调整生命年(DALYs)的潜在长期影响。然后,我们将经济框架应用于我们的估计,根据政府和全球资助者的支付能力来确定疫苗的可负担性,从而得出需求和市场规模的估计。根据我们的估计,考虑到目前的发病率和风险人群估计,在当前估计的发病率和风险人群的情况下,每剂(包括交付成本)利什曼病疫苗的最高支付能力高于 5 美元,考虑到需求数量的加权平均值,基于价值的最高价格为 5.7-6 美元[0.3-34.5 美元],需求量超过 5600 万剂。
结论/意义:我们的结果表明,考虑到的国家所需疫苗的数量及其支付能力,都可能使利什曼病疫苗对潜在制造商具有商业吸引力。所使用的方法同样适用于针对发展中国家卫生的其他技术开发。