Storz Maximilian Andreas
Tübingen, Germany.
Am J Lifestyle Med. 2020 Oct 14;16(3):300-310. doi: 10.1177/1559827620964755. eCollection 2022 May-Jun.
Low-fat, vegan diets seem to be particularly effective for glycemic control and may significantly lower hemoglobin A1c levels in individuals with type 2 diabetes. However, health care providers report low levels of practice and argue that this diet is hard to follow. This controversy on the acceptability of low-fat vegan diets appears to be a significant barrier to its broader clinical implementation. This review investigated dropout and adherence rates in intervention studies using a low-fat vegan diet in individuals with type 2 diabetes. In contrast to the common belief that this diet is poorly accepted, this review suggests different findings. Dietary adherence appears to be good with approximately 50% of individuals meeting the criteria for high adherence in most studies. Adherence to a low-fat vegan diet was higher than adherence to conventional diets in several studies. Group support and regular supervision improve adherence. Moreover, relatively low dropout rates were found-indirectly indicating good acceptance and high patient interest in this particular dietary modification. Although this review has several important limitations, it appears inappropriate to associate low-fat, vegan diets with poor adherence in individuals with type 2 diabetes. With good and regular support, adherence rates are more than solid and physicians should advocate for this diet more frequently.
低脂纯素饮食似乎对血糖控制特别有效,可能会显著降低2型糖尿病患者的糖化血红蛋白水平。然而,医疗保健提供者报告称这种饮食方式的实践程度较低,并认为这种饮食很难遵循。低脂纯素饮食可接受性方面的这一争议似乎是其更广泛临床应用的一个重大障碍。本综述调查了在2型糖尿病患者中使用低脂纯素饮食的干预研究中的退出率和依从率。与普遍认为这种饮食接受度差的观点相反,本综述提出了不同的结果。在大多数研究中,约50%的个体符合高依从性标准,饮食依从性似乎良好。在几项研究中,对低脂纯素饮食的依从性高于对传统饮食的依从性。团体支持和定期监督可提高依从性。此外,发现退出率相对较低——这间接表明对这种特殊饮食调整的接受度良好且患者兴趣浓厚。尽管本综述有几个重要局限性,但将低脂纯素饮食与2型糖尿病患者的低依从性联系起来似乎并不恰当。在良好且定期的支持下,依从率相当可观,医生应更频繁地推荐这种饮食。