Mo Chuan-Yu, Jin Jiyang, Jin Peiqi
School of Education and Music, Sanming University, Sanming, China.
Business School, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China.
Front Psychol. 2022 May 26;13:865445. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.865445. eCollection 2022.
Because of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, the traditional didactic teaching method that is practiced in Confucian culture, an Eastern cultural model, is being challenged by multiple alternative teaching modes. In Western cultures, the teaching behavior of teachers is dependent on their ability to influence the temperament of students; in contrast, teachers in Eastern cultures are influenced by changes in external environment (i.e., social policy). This phenomenon can mainly be explained by the tendency of students in Eastern cultures to adopt a passive learning style because of Confucianism. On the basis of Confucian culture and literature review, we conducted a Chinese-language questionnaire survey of temperament scales and learning motivation, and 724 effective questionnaires were collected and used to explore the relationship between students' temperament and learning motivation under three teaching modes, namely, online teaching, traditional offline classroom teaching, and online-offline mixed teaching. Conclusions drawn were as follows. (1) In a Chinese Confucian cultural system, the passive learning style of students and its relationship with the surrounding collective culture creates the temperament characteristics of sanguinity and phlegmatism. (2) Influenced by the traditional Confucian values of benevolence and honesty, students with a melancholic temperament do not focus on their learning motivations. Furthermore, changes in external information, to which such students are sensitive, cause them to give up opportunities easily. (3) Similarly, students with a choleric temperament are sensitive and prone to fluctuating emotions, and they tend to be affected by changes in their external environment. (4) Although students have a strong learning motivation under the traditional offline teaching mode, a paradox in individual cognition exists because of differences between Chinese and Western cultures. Therefore, students generally prefer the online-offline mixed teaching mode to the traditional single teaching mode. This study explored factors that influence students' learning motivation, namely, individual temperament and educational environment (e.g., teaching modes), and provides a reference for the future development of post epidemic education.
由于2019冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行,在东方文化模式的儒家文化中实行的传统讲授式教学方法正受到多种替代教学模式的挑战。在西方文化中,教师的教学行为取决于他们影响学生性情的能力;相比之下,东方文化中的教师则受外部环境(即社会政策)变化的影响。这种现象主要可以用东方文化中的学生因儒家思想而倾向于采用被动学习方式来解释。基于儒家文化并通过文献综述,我们对性情量表和学习动机进行了中文问卷调查,共收集到724份有效问卷,并用于探究在线教学、传统线下课堂教学和线上线下混合教学这三种教学模式下学生性情与学习动机之间的关系。得出的结论如下。(1)在中国儒家文化体系中,学生的被动学习方式及其与周围集体文化的关系塑造了 sanguinity 和 phlegmatism 的性情特征。(2)受传统儒家仁爱和诚信价值观的影响,性情忧郁的学生不关注自己的学习动机。此外,这类学生对外部信息变化敏感,容易放弃机会。(3)同样,性情暴躁的学生敏感且情绪容易波动,他们往往会受到外部环境变化的影响。(4)虽然在传统线下教学模式下学生有较强的学习动机,但由于中西方文化差异,个体认知中存在悖论。因此,与传统单一教学模式相比,学生普遍更喜欢线上线下混合教学模式。本研究探讨了影响学生学习动机的因素——个体性情和教育环境(如教学模式),为疫情后教育的未来发展提供了参考。