Moro Maria Francesca, Calamandrei Gemma, Poli Ranieri, Di Mattei Valentina, Perra Alessandra, Kurotschka Peter Konstantin, Restrepo Alexandra, Romano Ferdinando, La Torre Giuseppe, Preti Emanuele, Mascayano Franco, Picardi Angelo, Chiarotti Flavia, Rapisarda Venerando, Urban Antonio, Alvarado Ruben, Susser Ezra, Carta Mauro Giovanni
Department of Epidemiology, Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University, New York, NY, United States.
University of Cagliari, Cagliari, Italy.
Front Psychiatry. 2022 Jun 2;13:867080. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2022.867080. eCollection 2022.
Italy is one of the high-income countries hit hardest by Covid-19. During the first months of the pandemic, Italian healthcare workers were praised by media and the public for their efforts to face the emergency, although with limited knowledge and resources. However, healthcare workers soon had to face new challenges at a time when the national health system was working hard to recover. This study focuses on this difficult period to assess the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the mental health of Italian healthcare workers.
Healthcare workers from all Italian regions [ = 5,502] completed an online questionnaire during the reopening phase after the first wave lockdown. We assessed a set of individual-level factors (e.g., stigma and violence against HCWs) and a set of workplace-level factors (e.g., trust in the workplace capacity to handle COVID-19) that were especially relevant in this context. The primary outcomes assessed were score ≥15 on the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 and score ≥4 on the General Health Questionnaire-12, indicators of clinically significant depressive symptoms and psychological distress, respectively. Logistic regression analyses were performed on depressive symptoms and psychological distress for each individual- and workplace-level factor adjusting for gender, age, and profession.
Clinically significant depressive symptoms were observed in 7.5% and psychological distress in 37.9% of HCWs. 30.5% of healthcare workers reported having felt stigmatized or discriminated, while 5.7% reported having experienced violence. Feeling stigmatized or discriminated and experiencing violence due to being a healthcare worker were strongly associated with clinically significant depressive symptoms [OR 2.98, 95%CI 2.36-3.77 and OR 4.72 95%CI 3.41-6.54] and psychological distress [OR 2.30, 95%CI 2.01-2.64 and OR 2.85 95%CI 2.16-3.75]. Numerous workplace-level factors, e.g., trust in the workplace capacity to handle COVID-19 [OR 2.43, 95%CI 1.92-3.07] and close contact with a co-worker who died of COVID-19 [OR 2.05, 95%CI 1.56-2.70] were also associated with clinically significant depressive symptoms. Similar results were found for psychological distress.
Our study emphasizes the need to address discrimination and violence against healthcare professionals and improve healthcare work environments to strengthen the national health system's capacity to manage future emergencies.
意大利是受新冠疫情冲击最严重的高收入国家之一。在疫情的头几个月里,意大利医护人员尽管知识和资源有限,但他们应对紧急情况的努力受到了媒体和公众的赞扬。然而,在国家卫生系统努力恢复之际,医护人员很快就不得不面对新的挑战。本研究聚焦于这一艰难时期,以评估新冠疫情对意大利医护人员心理健康的影响。
来自意大利所有地区的医护人员(n = 5502)在第一波封锁后的重新开放阶段完成了一份在线问卷。我们评估了一系列个人层面的因素(例如,对医护人员的污名化和暴力行为)以及一系列工作场所层面的因素(例如,对工作场所应对新冠疫情能力的信任),这些因素在这种情况下尤为相关。评估的主要结果是患者健康问卷 - 9得分≥15分和一般健康问卷 - 12得分≥4分,分别是临床显著抑郁症状和心理困扰的指标。对每个个人和工作场所层面的因素进行逻辑回归分析,以调整性别、年龄和职业对抑郁症状和心理困扰的影响。
7.5%的医护人员出现了临床显著的抑郁症状,37.9%的医护人员存在心理困扰。30.5%的医护人员报告感到受到污名化或歧视,而5.7%的医护人员报告经历过暴力行为。因身为医护人员而感到受到污名化或歧视以及经历暴力行为与临床显著的抑郁症状[比值比(OR)2.98,95%置信区间(CI)2.36 - 3.77和OR 4.72,95%CI 3.41 - 6.54]和心理困扰[OR 2.30,95%CI 2.01 - 2.64和OR 2.85,95%CI 2.16 - 3.75]密切相关。许多工作场所层面的因素,例如对工作场所应对新冠疫情能力的信任[OR 2.43,95%CI 1.92 - 3.07]以及与死于新冠的同事密切接触[OR 2.05,95%CI 1.56 - 2.70]也与临床显著的抑郁症状相关。心理困扰方面也发现了类似结果。
我们的研究强调需要解决针对医护人员的歧视和暴力行为,并改善医疗工作环境,以加强国家卫生系统应对未来紧急情况的能力。