Siraj Md Sanwar
Department of Government and Politics, Jahangirnagar University, Dhaka, Bangladesh.
Asian Bioeth Rev. 2022 May 14;14(3):237-257. doi: 10.1007/s41649-022-00208-3. eCollection 2022 Jul.
Bangladesh, a Muslim-majority country, has a national organ donation law that was passed in 1999 and revised in 2018. The law allows living-related and brain-dead donor organ transplantation. There are no legal barriers to these two types of organ donations, but there is no legislation providing necessary costs and incentive measures associated with successful organ transplants. However, many governments across the globe provide different types of incentives for motivating living donors and families of deceased donors. This study assesses the merits and demerits of incentive measures already in use around the world and proposes ethical measures that can promote organ donation in Bangladesh. The primary focus of this paper is to present an ethical analysis of the comparison of incentive measures on organ donation between Bangladesh and the Islamic Republic of Iran as two Muslim countries that operate organ donation for transplantation practices according to Islamic principles. In this paper, I mainly argue that providing a fixed bare minimum financial incentive measure to distantly related living donors and families of deceased donors will encourage Bangladeshis to donate organs in a manner that is ethically justifiable, morally permissible, and socio-economically appropriate. The government of Bangladesh should revise the existing biomedical law to include a provision related to incentive measures and set a strict policy to properly regulate these measures as key stewardship that can ethically promote organ donation for transplantation.
孟加拉国是一个穆斯林占多数的国家,拥有一部于1999年通过并于2018年修订的国家器官捐赠法。该法律允许亲属活体捐赠和脑死亡捐赠者的器官移植。这两种器官捐赠不存在法律障碍,但没有立法规定与成功器官移植相关的必要费用和激励措施。然而,全球许多政府都提供不同类型的激励措施来鼓励活体捐赠者和已故捐赠者的家属。本研究评估了世界各地已采用的激励措施的优缺点,并提出了能够促进孟加拉国器官捐赠的伦理措施。本文的主要重点是对孟加拉国和伊朗伊斯兰共和国这两个根据伊斯兰原则开展器官移植捐赠活动的穆斯林国家在器官捐赠激励措施方面的比较进行伦理分析。在本文中,我主要认为,向远亲活体捐赠者和已故捐赠者的家属提供固定的最低限度经济激励措施,将鼓励孟加拉国人以符合伦理、道德允许且社会经济适宜的方式捐赠器官。孟加拉国政府应修订现行生物医学法,纳入与激励措施相关的条款,并制定严格政策,作为能够从伦理上促进器官移植捐赠的关键管理措施来妥善规范这些措施。