Health Division, American Institutes for Research, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, USA.
Health Division, American Institutes for Research, Arlington, Virginia, USA.
Health Serv Res. 2022 Dec;57 Suppl 2(Suppl 2):291-303. doi: 10.1111/1475-6773.14031. Epub 2022 Jul 22.
To advance equity by developing stakeholder-driven principles of shared measurement, which is using a common set of measurable goals that reflect shared priorities across communities and systems, such as health care, public health, and human and social services.
From October 2019 to July 2021, we collected primary data from leaders in cross-systems alignment, measurement, and community engagement-including community members and community-based organization leaders-across the United States.
In partnership with equity and community engagement experts, we conducted a mixed-methods study that included multiple formative research activities and culminated in a six-week, stakeholder-engaged modified-Delphi process.
Formative data collection occurred through an environmental scan, interviews, focus groups, and an online survey. Principles were developed using a virtual modified Delphi with iterative rapid-analysis. Feedback on the final principles was collected through virtual focus groups, an online feedback form, and during virtual presentations.
We developed a set of five guiding principles. Measurement that aligns systems with communities toward equitable outcomes: (1) Requires upfront investment in communities; (2) Is co-created by communities; (3) Creates accountability to communities for addressing root causes of inequities and repairing harm; (4) Focuses on a holistic and comprehensive view of communities that highlights assets and historical context; and (5) Reflects long-term efforts to build trust. Using an equity-focused process resulted in principles with broad applicability.
Leaders across systems and communities can use these shared measurement principles to reimagine and transform how systems create equitable health by centering the needs and priorities of the communities they serve, particularly communities that historically have been harmed the most by inequities. Intentionally centering equity across all project activities was essential to producing principles that could guide others in advancing equity.
通过制定利益相关者驱动的共同衡量原则来促进公平,即使用一套共同的可衡量目标,反映医疗保健、公共卫生以及人类和社会服务等各个社区和系统的共同重点。
从 2019 年 10 月至 2021 年 7 月,我们在美国各地的跨系统协调、衡量和社区参与的领导者中收集了原始数据,包括社区成员和社区组织领导者。
我们与公平和社区参与专家合作,进行了一项混合方法研究,其中包括多项形成性研究活动,并最终进行了为期六周的利益相关者参与式改良德尔菲法流程。
形成性数据收集通过环境扫描、访谈、焦点小组和在线调查进行。原则的制定采用了虚拟改良德尔菲法,并进行了迭代快速分析。通过虚拟焦点小组、在线反馈表和虚拟演示收集了对最终原则的反馈。
我们制定了一套五项指导原则。使系统与社区保持一致以实现公平结果的衡量:(1)需要对社区进行前期投资;(2)由社区共同创建;(3)为解决不平等的根本原因和修复伤害而对社区负责;(4)关注社区的整体和全面视角,突出资产和历史背景;(5)反映建立信任的长期努力。使用以公平为重点的流程产生了具有广泛适用性的原则。
跨系统和社区的领导者可以使用这些共同衡量原则来重新构想和改变系统如何通过关注他们所服务的社区的需求和重点来创造公平的健康,特别是那些历史上受到不平等伤害最大的社区。在所有项目活动中有意地关注公平是产生能够指导其他人推进公平的原则的关键。