Department of Physiology, Augusta University, Augusta, Georgia.
Department of Biostatistics, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
Am J Physiol Renal Physiol. 2022 Oct 1;323(4):F389-F400. doi: 10.1152/ajprenal.00427.2021. Epub 2022 Jul 14.
Competent statistical analysis is essential to maintain rigor and reproducibility in physiological research. Unfortunately, the benefits offered by statistics are often negated by misuse or inadequate reporting of statistical methods. To address the need for improved quality of statistical analysis in papers, the released guidelines for reporting statistics in journals published by the society. The guidelines reinforce high standards for the presentation of statistical data in physiology but focus on the conceptual challenges and, thus, may be of limited use to an unprepared reader. Experimental scientists working in the renal field may benefit from putting the existing guidelines in a practical context. This paper discusses the application of widespread hypothesis tests in a confirmatory study. We simulated pharmacological experiments assessing intracellular calcium in cultured renal cells and kidney function at the systemic level to review best practices for data analysis, graphical presentation, and reporting. Such experiments are ubiquitously used in renal physiology and could be easily translated to other practical applications to fit the reader's specific needs. We provide step-by-step guidelines for using the most common types of tests and ANOVA and discuss typical mistakes associated with them. We also briefly consider normality tests, exclusion criteria, and identification of technical and experimental replicates. This review is supposed to help the reader analyze, illustrate, and report the findings correctly and will hopefully serve as a gauge for a level of design complexity when it might be time to consult a biostatistician.
在生理学研究中,进行有效的统计分析对于确保严谨性和可重复性至关重要。然而,由于统计方法的误用或不充分报告,统计带来的益处往往被抵消。为了提高论文中统计分析质量,该学会发布了期刊中统计学报告的指南。这些指南强化了生理学中统计数据呈现的高标准,但重点关注概念性挑战,因此,对于没有准备的读者可能作用有限。从事肾脏领域实验科学的人员可能会受益于将现有指南应用于实际情况。本文讨论了广泛应用于确证性研究中的假设检验方法。我们模拟了评估培养的肾脏细胞内钙离子和系统水平肾功能的药理学实验,以回顾数据分析、图形呈现和报告的最佳实践。此类实验在肾脏生理学中普遍使用,并且可以轻松应用于其他实际应用,以满足读者的特定需求。我们提供了使用最常见类型的 t 检验和 ANOVA 的分步指南,并讨论了与之相关的典型错误。我们还简要考虑了正态性检验、排除标准以及技术和实验重复的识别。本综述旨在帮助读者正确地分析、说明和报告研究结果,并希望为读者在需要咨询生物统计学家时提供一个衡量设计复杂性的标准。