Division of Social Science, New York University Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates.
Department of Political Science, National Cheng Kung University, Taiwan.
Soc Sci Med. 2022 Oct;310:115278. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2022.115278. Epub 2022 Aug 15.
What types of vaccines are citizens most likely to accept? We argue that citizens' identification with their nation may lead them to prefer vaccines developed and produced within their national borders, to the exclusion and/or detriment of vaccines from other nations. We administered a conjoint experiment requesting 15,000 adult citizens across 14 individual countries from around the world to assess 450,000 profiles of vaccines that randomly varied on seven attributes. Beyond vaccine fundamentals such as efficacy rate, number of doses, and duration of the protection, we find that citizens systematically favor vaccines developed and produced in their own country of residence. The extent of preference in favor of vaccines developed and produced within the national borders is particularly large among citizens who identify more strongly with their nation, suggesting nationalism plays a role in explaining the bias in favor of vaccines developed and produced locally. This public opinion bias on vaccine preferences has significant theoretical and practical implications.
公民最有可能接受哪些类型的疫苗?我们认为,公民对自己国家的认同可能使他们更倾向于接受在本国开发和生产的疫苗,而排斥和/或损害来自其他国家的疫苗。我们进行了一项联合实验,要求来自世界各地的 14 个国家的 15000 名成年公民评估 45 万种疫苗的情况,这些疫苗在七个属性上随机变化。除了疫苗的基本要素,如有效率、剂量数和保护持续时间外,我们发现公民系统地偏爱在自己居住的国家开发和生产的疫苗。在那些对自己国家认同感更强的公民中,这种对在本国开发和生产的疫苗的偏好程度尤其大,这表明民族主义在解释对本地开发和生产的疫苗的偏好偏见方面发挥了作用。这种对疫苗偏好的公众意见偏见具有重要的理论和实践意义。