Li Hongjiao, Ai Yanke, Zhao Tianyi, Zhang Di, Lv Xiaoying, Jia Shaoyan, Wen Zehuai, Li Guoxin, Wang Hongyu, Gao Feng, Li Shaohong, Ge Zhishan, Qin Yuning, Wang Zhenbiao, He Liyun
Institute of Basic Research in Clinical Medicine, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing, China.
Hospital of Beihang University, Beijing, China.
Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2022 Sep 1;2022:9968171. doi: 10.1155/2022/9968171. eCollection 2022.
Observational studies from China suggest that Kangbingdu oral liquid (KBD) may be effective in treating the common cold.
Reevaluation of efficacy and safety of Kangbingdu oral liquid after marketing and expanding population.
Prospective, Pragmatic randomized controlled trial (Chictr.org.cn registration number: chiCTR-TRC-12002399). . Eleven hospitals from 3 provinces in China. Patients were recruited through 11 centers, including 7 teaching hospitals, 2 University health services, one military clinic, and one community hospital. . 2647 persons aged 18 to 75 years with Common cold. . Patients were randomly allocated to 2 groups: the treatment group Kangbingdu oral liquid (composed of 9 Chinese herbal medicines and honey) and the placebo group were divided into a standard-dose group of 10 ml every time, a middle dose group of 20 ml every time, high dose group of 30 ml every time, 3 times daily. Interventions and control were given for 5 days. . The primary outcome is the mean amount of total scores measured by the 11-primary symptoms: to observe the change of main symptoms from severe to disappear and to calculate and compare the mean amount of total scores after the periods of observation. Secondary outcomes are the disappearance rate of each symptom and the median time of body temperature returned to normal.
On day 5, the Kangbingdu liquid group had significant reductions in the mean amount of total scores measured by the 11-primary symptoms (7.39 [95% CI 7.26 to 7.51] compared to the placebo group (6.43 [95%: CI 6.24 to 6.62]). The Kangbingdu liquid can improve the remission rate of accompanying symptoms on day 5 including aversion to wind, aversion to cold, fever, cough, stuffy, runny nose, sore throat, muscular aches, headache, fatigue, and sweat ( < 0.0001). Significant reductions in time of body temperature to return to normal in the Kangbingdu liquid group (P50, 48.33 [95% CI 46.00 to 52.50] compared with the control group (P50, 64.59 [95% CI 51.08 to 70.50] (=0.0022). 13 (0.7%) participants in the Kangbingdu liquid group and 1(0.2%) participants in the placebo group ( > 0.05) had treatment-related AEs, which mainly include diarrhea and dyspepsia in the Kangbingdu liquid group and constipation in the placebo group.
The study's conclusion in this paper was based on the placebo, Kangbingdu oral liquid two groups which clinically diagnosed the common cold and flu. (1) Kangbingdu oral liquid can effectively improve the comprehensive clinical symptoms of common adult cold, also improved main symptoms, including sore throat, muscle aches, headache, and so on. (2) Kangbingdu oral liquid effectively shortens the time of body temperature to return to normal.
来自中国的观察性研究表明,抗病毒口服液(KBD)可能对治疗普通感冒有效。
重新评估抗病毒口服液上市后扩大人群使用时的疗效和安全性。
前瞻性、实用随机对照试验(在中国临床试验注册中心注册,注册号:chiCTR-TRC-12002399)。来自中国3个省份的11家医院。通过11个中心招募患者,包括7家教学医院、2家大学健康服务机构、1家军队诊所和1家社区医院。2647名年龄在18至75岁的普通感冒患者。患者被随机分为2组:治疗组为抗病毒口服液(由9种中药和蜂蜜组成),安慰剂组分为每次10毫升标准剂量组、每次20毫升中剂量组、每次30毫升高剂量组,每日3次。干预和对照均进行5天。主要结局是通过11项主要症状测量的总分平均值:观察主要症状从严重到消失的变化,并计算和比较观察期后的总分平均值。次要结局是每种症状的消失率和体温恢复正常的中位时间。
在第5天,抗病毒口服液组通过11项主要症状测量的总分平均值显著降低(7.39 [95%可信区间7.26至7.51]),而安慰剂组为(6.43 [95%可信区间6.24至6.62])。抗病毒口服液可提高第5天伴随症状的缓解率,包括恶寒、恶风、发热、咳嗽、鼻塞、流涕、咽痛、肌肉酸痛、头痛、乏力、汗出(P<0.0001)。抗病毒口服液组体温恢复正常的时间显著缩短(P50,48.33 [95%可信区间46.00至52.50]),而对照组为(P50,64.59 [95%可信区间51.08至70.50])(P = 0.0022)。抗病毒口服液组13名(0.7%)参与者和安慰剂组1名(0.2%)参与者出现与治疗相关的不良事件(P>0.05),抗病毒口服液组主要包括腹泻和消化不良,安慰剂组为便秘。
本文研究结论基于安慰剂、抗病毒口服液两组临床诊断的普通感冒和流感患者。(1)抗病毒口服液可有效改善成人普通感冒的综合临床症状,并改善主要症状,包括咽痛、肌肉酸痛、头痛等。(2)抗病毒口服液有效缩短体温恢复正常的时间。