Tabbal Judie, Kabbara Aya, Yochum Maxime, Khalil Mohamad, Hassan Mahmoud, Benquet Pascal
Institute of Clinical Neurosciences of Rennes (INCR), Rennes, France.
MINDig, F-35000 Rennes, France.
J Neural Eng. 2022 Oct 11;19(5). doi: 10.1088/1741-2552/ac954f.
Electro/Magnetoencephalography (EEG/MEG) source-space network analysis is increasingly recognized as a powerful tool for tracking fast electrophysiological brain dynamics. However, an objective and quantitative evaluation of pipeline steps is challenging due to the lack of realistic 'controlled' data. Here, our aim is two-folded: (a) provide a quantitative assessment of the advantages and limitations of the analyzed techniques and (b) introduce (and share) a complete framework that can be used to optimize the entire pipeline of EEG/MEG source connectivity.We used a human brain computational model containing both physiologically based cellular GABAergic and Glutamatergic circuits coupled through Diffusion Tensor Imaging, to generate high-density EEG recordings. We designed a scenario of successive gamma-band oscillations in distinct cortical areas to emulate a virtual picture-naming task. We identified fast time-varying network states and quantified the performance of the key steps involved in the pipeline: (a) inverse models to reconstruct cortical-level sources, (b) functional connectivity measures to compute statistical interdependency between regional signals, and (c) dimensionality reduction methods to derive dominant brain network states (BNS).Using a systematic evaluation of the different decomposition techniques, results show significant variability among tested algorithms in terms of spatial and temporal accuracy. We outlined the spatial precision, the temporal sensitivity, and the global accuracy of the extracted BNS relative to each method. Our findings suggest a good performance of weighted minimum norm estimate/ Phase Locking Value combination to elucidate the appropriate functional networks and ICA techniques to derive relevant dynamic BNS.We suggest using such brain models to go further in the evaluation of the different steps and parameters involved in the EEG/MEG source-space network analysis. This can reduce the empirical selection of inverse model, connectivity measure, and dimensionality reduction method as some of the methods can have a considerable impact on the results and interpretation.
脑电/脑磁图(EEG/MEG)源空间网络分析日益被视为追踪快速脑电生理动力学的有力工具。然而,由于缺乏现实的“受控”数据,对流程步骤进行客观定量评估具有挑战性。在此,我们有两个目标:(a)对所分析技术的优缺点进行定量评估,以及(b)引入(并分享)一个可用于优化EEG/MEG源连接性整个流程的完整框架。我们使用一个包含通过扩散张量成像耦合的基于生理的细胞GABA能和谷氨酸能回路的人脑计算模型,来生成高密度EEG记录。我们设计了一个在不同皮质区域连续进行伽马波段振荡的场景,以模拟虚拟图片命名任务。我们识别了快速时变网络状态,并量化了流程中关键步骤的性能:(a)用于重建皮质水平源的逆模型,(b)用于计算区域信号之间统计相关性的功能连接性测量,以及(c)用于推导主要脑网络状态(BNS)的降维方法。通过对不同分解技术的系统评估,结果表明在空间和时间准确性方面,测试算法之间存在显著差异。我们概述了相对于每种方法提取的BNS的空间精度、时间敏感性和全局准确性。我们的研究结果表明,加权最小范数估计/锁相值组合在阐明适当的功能网络方面表现良好,并采用独立成分分析(ICA)技术来推导相关的动态BNS。我们建议使用此类脑模型进一步评估EEG/MEG源空间网络分析中涉及的不同步骤和参数。这可以减少对逆模型、连接性测量和降维方法的经验性选择,因为其中一些方法可能会对结果和解释产生相当大的影响。